Striving for Consensus: How Panels Evaluate Artistic Productions
Open Access
- 10 December 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Qualitative Sociology
- Vol. 43 (1) , 21-42
Abstract
Researchers have studied how artistic judgments are made in group interactions, but much remains to be known about artistic evaluations in decision-making settings where agreements need to be reached. This paper analyzes panel evaluations of artistic productions, drawing on interviews with panelists from a Polish theater competition. The article focuses on two aspects of panel decision-making: (1) concepts of artistic value that members of expert panels apply when evaluating art productions; and (2) interpersonal rules of deliberation, that is, norms and patterns of behavior that allow panelists to attach legitimacy to the decision-making process and its outcomes. The authors find that panel evaluations are based on a combination of two different logics (content and context logic) and develop a matrix of values the conceptualizes artistic standards and their applications. Furthermore, the authors find that panelists follow three types of interpersonal rules for decision-making:substantive,procedural, andcontextual.Keywords
Funding Information
- The Aleksander Zelwerowicz State Warsaw Academy of Drama
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dimensions of Conventionality and Innovation in Film: The Cultural Classification of Blockbusters, Award Winners, and Critics’ FavouritesCultural Sociology, 2013
- Which decision‐making arrangements generate the strongest legitimacy beliefs? Evidence from a randomised field experimentEuropean Journal of Political Research, 2012
- If the People Like It, It Must Be Good: Criticism, Democracy and the Culture of ConsensusCultural Sociology, 2012
- Art and Social Value RegimesCurrent Sociology, 2005
- What is Originality in the Humanities and the Social Sciences?American Sociological Review, 2004
- Expert panels evaluating research: decision-making and sources of biasResearch Evaluation, 2004
- Social Influence: Compliance and ConformityAnnual Review of Psychology, 2004
- The Effects of Extroversion on Influence in Ambiguous Group TasksSmall Group Research, 2000
- A Measure of OriginalitySocial Studies of Science, 1999
- Boundary-Work and the Demarcation of Science from Non-Science: Strains and Interests in Professional Ideologies of ScientistsAmerican Sociological Review, 1983