Evaluating Perceptional Tasks for Medicine: A Comparative User Study Between a Virtual Reality and a Desktop Application
Authors:
- 1 March 2022
- conference paper
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)
- p. 514-523
Abstract
Since for most consumers the Virtual Reality (VR) experience exceeds that of desktop applications, an increasing number of applications is being transferred from desktop to VR. Industrial and entertainment applications primarily expect for a richer consumer experience, while others, such as surgical applications, seek for improved precision over their desktop counterparts. One way to improve the performance of precision-based VR applications is to provide suitable visualizations. Today, these "suitable" visualizations are mostly transferred from desktop to VR without considering their spatial and temporal performance might change in VR. This may not lead to an optimal solution, which can be crucial for precision-based tasks. Misinterpretation of shape or distance in a surgical or pre-operative simulation can affect the chosen treatment and thus directly impact the outcome. Therefore, we evaluate the performance differences of multiple visualizations for 3D surfaces based on their shape and distance estimation for desktop and VR applications. We conducted a quantitative user study with 56 participants evaluating seven visualizations (Phong, Toon, Fresnel, Pseudo-Chromadepth, Heatmap, Isolines, and Arrow Glyphs). Our results show that the performance of each visualization varies depending on the task, system, and surface type, with VR generally providing improved results. While Isolines are able to improve distance estimation, Phong and Heatmaps are beneficial for shape estimation.Keywords
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effects of balance training using a virtual-reality system in older fallersClinical Interventions in Aging, 2013
- The effects of head-mounted display mechanical properties and field of view on distance judgments in virtual environmentsACM Transactions on Applied Perception, 2009
- Training with simulation improves residents’ endovascular procedure skillsJournal of Vascular Surgery, 2007
- Disparity-defined objects moving in depth do not elicit three-dimensional shape constancyVision Research, 2006
- Visual complexity: A review.Psychological Bulletin, 2006
- Inference by Eye: Confidence Intervals and How to Read Pictures of Data.American Psychologist, 2005
- Does the Quality of the Computer Graphics Matter when Judging Distances in Visually Immersive Environments?PRESENCE: Virtual and Augmented Reality, 2004
- Limited Field of View of Head-Mounted Displays Is Not the Cause of Distance Underestimation in Virtual EnvironmentsPRESENCE: Virtual and Augmented Reality, 2004
- Stereoscopic Depth Constancy Depends on the Subject's TaskVision Research, 1996
- Illumination for computer generated picturesCommunications of the ACM, 1975