In Flanders Fields: De/politicization and Democratic Debate on a GM Potato Field Trial Controversy in News Media
Authors:
- Pieter MaeseelePMPieter Maeseele
- Daniëlle RaeijmaekersDRDaniëlle Raeijmaekers
- Laurens Van der SteenLSLaurens Van der Steen
- Robin ReulRRRobin Reul
- Steve PaulussenSPSteve Paulussen
- 6 October 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Environmental Communication
- Vol. 11 (2) , 166-183
Abstract
In May 2011, a highly mediatized direct action in the form of a “field liberation” took place in Flanders, Belgium, against a field trial of genetically modified potatoes. This direct action and its aftermath revealed the conflictual and antagonistic nature of the genetically modified organisms debate in Flanders. Consequently, it serves as a particularly suitable case to investigate the post-political thesis with regard to environmental discourse and politics. The aim of this paper is to investigate in what ways news media in their reporting contribute to processes of depoliticization and, resultantly, impede a democratic debate on the issues at stake. This paper attempts to provide an answer to this question based on a critical discourse analysis of the reporting by Flanders’ two generalist, elite newspapers, De Standaard and De Morgen and the alternative online news site DeWereldMorgen. The findings reveal the existence of three ideological cultures, which are characterized by different degrees of de/politicization. We conclude by discussing how this study adds to our understanding of the relation between the depoliticization of environmental discourse, democratic debate and twenty-first-century news media.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Searching for ‘the political’ in environmental politicsEnvironmental Politics, 2014
- Risk conflicts, critical discourse analysis and media discourses on GM crops and foodJournalism, 2013
- Lost in Translation: Climate Denial and the Return of the PoliticalGlobal Environmental Politics, 2012
- Beyond individual behaviour change: the role of power, knowledge and strategy in tackling climate changeEnvironmental Education Research, 2012
- On news media and democratic debate: Framing agricultural biotechnology in Northern BelgiumInternational Communication Gazette, 2011
- On Neo-luddites led by Ayatollahs: The Frame Matrix of the GM Food Debate in Northern BelgiumEnvironmental Communication, 2010
- Apocalypse Forever?Theory, Culture & Society, 2010
- Biotech as `biothreat'?: metaphorical constructions in discourseDiscourse & Society, 2008
- Newspapers' production of common senseJournalism, 2007
- News coverage of biotechnology debatesSociety, 2003