Variation in Surgical Opinion Regarding Management of Selected Cervical Spine Injuries
Authors:
- Beth A. JaworskiBJBeth A. Jaworski
- Brian G. CuddyBCBrian G. Cuddy
- Todd J. AlbertTATodd J. Albert
- James P. HollowellJHJames P. Hollowell
- Robert F. McLainRMRobert F. McLain
- Samuel A. BozzetteSBSamuel A. Bozzette
- 1 May 1998
- journal article
- case report
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Spine
- Vol. 23 (9) , 975-982
Abstract
The opinions of orthopedic surgeons and neurosurgeons were compared regarding appropriate management of selected cervical injuries and the timing of stabilization. To determine whether there is consistency of opinion regarding the management of cervical trauma. Numerous forms of management for cervical trauma exist, but there are few consistent recommendations. No previous study has been done to determine uniformity of preferences of the surgeons who manage these injuries. Thirty-one orthopedic surgeons and neurosurgeons were given a brief clinical situation and pertinent radiographic studies of five selected cervical injuries. Management options included halo and nonhalo orthoses, traction, and various forms of anterior and/or posterior procedures. The surgeons rated, in whole numbers from 1 to 10, their opinions on the appropriateness of each technique. Each surgeon was given a case of a "generic" cervical injury, in which stabilization was required and for which preoperative alignment was adequate in traction. They gave opinions on the timing of stabilization, with a choice of four time frames. Four neurologic situations were rated, ranging from intact to complete cord injury. Of 46 possible responses to the five test cases regarding appropriateness, 18 ranged from 1 to 10, the largest possible variation. Only 2 had a range of 5 or less, implying better consensus among tested surgeons. Mean values ranged from 1.9 to 9.5. Agreementamong respondents regarding appropriateness was slight with a range of kappa statistics from 0.09 to 0.14. Of 16 possible responses regarding timing, 14 were within a range of 8 or higher. Within 24 to 72 hours was the generally preferred time frame, with all possible responses showing a range of 3 or 4. Results of a multiple analysis of variance showed no significant differences among respondents. There is a large variety of opinion regarding appropriateness of specific operative and nonoperative management procedures and surgical timing among the surgeons polled who manage cervical trauma. This implies that there is no widely accepted standard management procedure for many of these injuries.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Anterior Screw Fixation of Type II Odontoid FracturesSpine, 1995
- Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Minerva Cervicothoracic OrthosisSpine, 1995
- The Thermoplastic Minerva Body JacketJournal of Spinal Disorders, 1992
- Biomechanics of Cervical Spine Internal FixationSpine, 1991
- Herniated Intervertebral Discs Associated with Unstable Spinal InjuriesSpine, 1990
- Written case simulations: Do they predict physicians' behavior?Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1990
- Management of Post-traumatic Cervical Spine Instability1988
- Halo-Thoracic Brace Management of Odontoid FracturesSpine, 1979
- Non-operative management of acute upper cervical injuriesActa Neurochirurgica, 1978
- Clinical Instability in the Lower Cervical Spine A Review of Past and Current ConceptsSpine, 1976