An ineffective “Big Brother”: Israeli COVID-19 technological tracing strategy
- 29 April 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Corporate Communications: An International Journal
- Vol. 30 (4) , 724-740
Abstract
Purpose: This study examines Israel’s unique use of the General Security Service (GSS) for COVID-19 contact tracing, analyzing its effectiveness and implications for public health and civil liberties.Design/methodology/approach: Using a case study framework, the research evaluates Israel’s dual approach: the compulsory GSS “Tool” and the voluntary HAMAGEN app. A comprehensive matrix is introduced to assess legal, democratic, socio-economic and epidemiological factors.Findings: The study reveals that the GSS geo-tracking proved ineffective in curbing COVID-19, leading to privacy infringements, public distrust, economic harm from false quarantines and limited epidemiological benefits.Social implications: This interdisciplinary analysis highlights key lessons for global crisis policies, advocating for proportionality, transparency, judicial oversight and minimally invasive technologies. The findings serve as a cautionary tale, illustrating the risks of surveillance-driven health interventions.Originality/value: As the only democracy to deploy its secret service for pandemic management, Israel offers a critical case study. This interdisciplinary analysis highlights key lessons for global crisis policies, advocating for proportionality, transparency, judicial oversight and minimally invasive technologies. The findings serve as a cautionary tale, illustrating the risks of surveillance-driven health interventions.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- COVID-19 digital contact tracing applications and techniques: A review post initial deploymentsTransportation Engineering, 2021
- State surveillance and the COVID-19 crisisJournal of Human Rights, 2020
- Israeli Intelligence and the Coronavirus CrisisInternational Journal of Intelligence and CounterIntelligence, 2020
- Civil libertiesorpublic health, or civil libertiesandpublic health? Using surveillance technologies to tackle the spread of COVID-19Space and Polity, 2020
- Mass-surveillance technologies to fight coronavirus spread: the case of IsraelNature Medicine, 2020
- Mass surveillance in the age of COVID-19Journal of Law and the Biosciences, 2020
- Feasibility of controlling COVID-19 outbreaks by isolation of cases and contactsThe Lancet Global Health, 2020
- De-militarization as political self-marginalization: Israeli Labor Party and the MISEs (members of Israeli security elite) 1977–2015Israel Affairs, 2016
- Surveillance Studies2015
- “Second Class Loss”: Political Culture as a Recovery Barrier—The Families of Terrorist Casualties' Struggle for National Honors, Recognition, and BelongingDeath Studies, 2013