Comparing Staffing Levels in the Online Survey Certification and Reporting (OSCAR) System With the Medicaid Cost Report Data: Are Differences Systematic?
Authors:
- Bita A. KashBKBita A. Kash
- Catherine HawesCHCatherine Hawes
- Charles D. PhillipsCPCharles D. Phillips
Open Access
- 1 August 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The Gerontologist
- Vol. 47 (4) , 480-489
Abstract
Purpose: This study had two goals: (a) to assess the validity of the Online Survey Certification and Reporting (OSCAR) staffing data by comparing them to staffing measures from audited Medicaid Cost Reports and (b) to identify systematic differences between facilities that over-report or underreport staffing in the OSCAR. Design and Methods: We merged the 2002 Texas Nursing Facility Cost Report, the OSCAR for Texas facilities surveyed in 2002, and the 2003 Area Resource File. We eliminated outliers in the OSCAR using three decision rules, resulting in a final sample size of 941 of the total of 1,017 non-hospital-based facilities. We compared OSCAR and Medicaid Cost Report staffing measures for three staff types. We examined differences between facilities that over-reported or underreported staffing levels in the OSCAR by using logistic regression. Results: Average staffing levels were higher in the OSCAR than in the Medicaid Cost Report data. The two sets of measures exhibited correlations ranging between 0.5 and 0.6. For-profit and larger facilities consistently over-reported registered nurse staffing levels. Factors associated with increased odds of over-reporting licensed vocational nursing or certified nursing assistant staffing were lower Medicare or Medicaid censuses and less market competition. Facility characteristics associated with over-reporting were consistent across different levels of over-reporting. Underreporting was much less prevalent. Implications: Certain types of facilities consistently over-report staffing levels. These reporting errors will affect the validity of consumer information systems, regulatory activities, and health services research results, particularly research using OSCAR data to examine the relationship between staffing and quality. Results call for a more accurate reporting system.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic Review of Studies of Staffing and Quality in Nursing HomesJournal of the American Medical Directors Association, 2006
- Improving the Quality of Long‐Term Care with Better InformationThe Milbank Quarterly, 2005
- Nurse staffing levels and quality of care in Northeastern Pennsylvania nursing homesApplied Nursing Research, 2005
- The Wheat Valley Assisted Living Culture: RITUALS AND RULESJournal of Gerontological Nursing, 2005
- Physician and nurse staffing in nursing homes: The role and limitations of the Online Survey Certification and Reporting (OSCAR) systemJournal of the American Medical Directors Association, 2005
- The Minimum Data Set Prevalence of Restraint Quality Indicator: Does It Reflect Differences in Care?The Gerontologist, 2004
- Nursing Home Staffing and Quality Under the Nursing Home Reform ActThe Gerontologist, 2004
- Nursing Home Quality, Cost, Staffing, and Staff MixThe Gerontologist, 2004
- Reliability Estimates for The Minimum Data Set for Nursing Home Resident Assessment and Care Screening (MDS)The Gerontologist, 1995
- Refining a Case-Mix Measure for Nursing Homes: Resource Utilization Groups (RUG-III)Medical Care, 1994