20 Years Since the Enactment of Italian Law No. 40/2004 on Medically Assisted Procreation: How It Has Changed and How It Could Change
Open Access
- 17 February 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 22 (2) , 296
Abstract
The article examines the changes to Italian legislation on assisted reproductive technology (ART) resulting from rulings by Italian courts, highlighting unresolved ethical–legal issues and potential future regulatory approaches consistent with these decisions. Additionally, it addresses the amendment defining surrogacy as “universal crime”, effective as of 18 November 2024. Through an analysis of decisions by the Constitutional Court and the Court of Cassation, it emerges that Law No. 40/2004 has been deemed unconstitutional in relation to the following: heterologous fertilization, the number of embryos that can be created, cryopreservation, the implantation of only healthy embryos, and access to ART for fertile couples. Controversial aspects include the fate of surplus embryos, access to ART for single individuals, and the recognition of parenthood for same-sex couples. The “universal crime” classification of surrogacy raises the possibility of legal consequences for individuals engaging in surrogacy abroad, even where it is lawful. Courts are unlikely to legislate on the allocation of surplus embryos without parliamentary intervention or to allow single individuals access to ART, given the perceived inconsistency with the child’s best interests. However, case-by-case evaluations are essential for recognizing non-biological or non-genetic parents in same-sex relationships and for assessing the effectiveness of the universal crime approach in safeguarding rights and public health.Keywords
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- Navigating the gestational surrogacy seas: the legalities and complexities of gestational carrier servicesJournal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, 2024
- The legally charged issue of cross-border surrogacy: Current regulatory challenges and future prospectsEuropean Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology, 2024
- Unraveling Informality and Precarity: New Labor Law Strategies for the Global Reproduction Network of Cross-Border SurrogacyAsian Bioethics Review, 2023
- Potentiality switches and epistemic uncertainty: the Argument from Potential in times of human embryo-like structuresMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2023
- Womb to rent: the ethical and legal implications of surrogacy in IrelandIrish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -), 2023
- Gonadotropin Stimulation Reduces the Implantation and Live Birth Rate but Not the Miscarriage Rate of Embryos Transferred When Compared to Unstimulated In Vitro FertilizationReproductive Sciences, 2022
- The ethics of fertility treatment for same-sex male couples: Considerations for a modern fertility clinicEuropean Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology, 2020
- Ethical issues and law-making power: how European case law has rewritten Italian law on medically assisted reproductionMonash Bioethics Review, 2018
- Narrative Identity in Third Party Reproduction: Normative Aspects and Ethical ChallengesJournal of Bioethical Inquiry, 2017
- Donation of surplus frozen embryos for stem cell research or fertility treatment—Should medical professionals and healthcare institutions be allowed to exercise undue influence on the informed decision of their former patients?Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics, 2006