Referendum Design and Contingent Valuation: The NOAA Panel's No-vote Recommendation

Authors:
  • RCRichard T. Carson
    Richard T. Carson
  • WHW. Michael Hanemann
    W. Michael Hanemann
  • RKRaymond J. Kopp
    Raymond J. Kopp
  • JKJon A. Krosnick
    Jon A. Krosnick
  • RMRobert Cameron Mitchell
    Robert Cameron Mitchell
  • SPStanley Presser
    Stanley Presser
  • PRPaul A. Ruud
    Paul A. Ruud
  • VSV. Kerry Smith
    V. Kerry Smith
  • MCMichael Conaway
    Michael Conaway
  • KMKerry Martin
    Kerry Martin

Abstract
This paper considers the effects for offering a "would-not-vote" option in contingent valuation (CV) questions framed using the referendum format. This approach arises from a suggestion made by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA) panel on contingent valuation. The NOAA panel was asked to evaluate the use of this method for estimating the economic value of nonmarketed environmental resources in the context of natural resource damage assessments. This test used the CV questionnaire developed for the study of the Exxon Valdez oil spill conducted by the State of Alaska with in-person interviews. The findings suggest that when those selecting the "would-not-vote" response are treated as having voted "against" the program (a conservative coding), offering this option does not alter (1) the distribution of "for" and "against" responses (2) the estimates of willingness to pay derived from these choices, or (3) the construct validity of the results. © 1998 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology