A Blind Controlled Trial of Phase-Contrast Microscopy by Two Observers for Evaluating the Source of Haematuria

Authors:
  • GRG. Venkat Raman
    G. Venkat Raman
  • LPLinda Pead
    Linda Pead
  • HLH.A. Lee
    H.A. Lee
  • RMRosalind Maskell
    Rosalind Maskell

Abstract
Two observers, unaware of each other’s findings and of the diagnosis, examined red cells in the urine of 109 patients by phase-contrast microscopy. All specimens were examined uncentrifuged by inverted microscopy, and 48 of the 109 were also examined under a light microscope after centrifugation. We were unable to confirm with either method the close correlation between red-cell morphology and diagnosis reported in previous studies, and our 2 observers differed in their interpretation on 38% of occasions. Proteinuria associated with the presence of casts in uncentrifuged urine examined by inverted microscopy was a better indication than red-cell morphology of renal parenchymal disease.