Abstract
It is paradoxical to conclude this volume by lauding its excellence. The authors have done an impressive job of making the very term “excellence” one that we view with suspicion. By asking us to consider both the purposes that the concept of excellence is now serving and the difficulty of measuring it in a way that will make it better able to serve the cause of gender equity, the book steers a course between the positions Kathrin Zippel and I identified as Pollyanna and Cassandra perspectives (Ferree and Zippel 2015). On the one hand, some chapters point out what is wrong with how excellence is assessed and offer constructive suggestions for reforming the current measurements of excellence in ways that will identify built-in biases and make the outcomes more inclusive in practice (see especially chapters by Honig; Callersteig; Schiffbaenker, Besselaar, and Holzinger). On the other hand, the editors' introduction and some of the chapters deconstruct excellence as a concept as well as a contemporary practice and point to the dangers for advocates of gender equity inherent in trying to use such a shape-shifting idea to buttress claims of injustice (see Saekula et al.; Aavik and Marling; Wegrzyn et al; Wolffram).