It's time we put agency into Behavioural Public Policy
Open Access
- 21 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Behavioural Public Policy
- Vol. 8 (4) , 789-806
Abstract
Promoting agency – people's ability to form intentions and to act on them freely – must become a primary objective for Behavioural Public Policy (BPP). Contemporary BPPs do not directly pursue this objective, which is problematic for many reasons. From an ethical perspective, goals like personal autonomy and individual freedom cannot be realised without nurturing citizens’ agency. From an efficacy standpoint, BPPs that override agency – for example, by activating automatic psychological processes – leave citizens ‘in the dark’, incapable of internalising and owning the process of behaviour change. This may contribute to non-persistent treatment effects, compensatory negative spillovers or psychological reactance and backfiring effects. In this paper, we argue agency-enhancing BPPs can alleviate these ethical and efficacy limitations to longer-lasting and meaningful behaviour change. We set out philosophical arguments to help us understand and conceptualise agency. Then, we review three alternative agency-enhancing behavioural frameworks: (1) boosts to enhance people's competences to make better decisions; (2) debiasing to encourage people to reduce the tendency for automatic, impulsive responses; and (3) nudge+ to enable citizens to think alongside nudges and evaluate them transparently. Using a multi-dimensional framework, we highlight differences in their workings, which offer comparative insights and complementarities in their use. We discuss limitations of agency-enhancing BPPs and map out future research directions.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Thinking through norms can make them more effective. Experimental evidence on reflective climate policies in the UKJournal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 2023
- Behavioural public policies for the social brainBehavioural Public Policy, 2023
- When and why defaults influence decisions: a meta-analysis of default effectsBehavioural Public Policy, 2019
- ‘Better off, as judged by themselves’: a reply to Cass SunsteinInternational Review of Economics, 2017
- The Power to NudgeAmerican Political Science Review, 2017
- Nudge Versus Boost: How Coherent are Policy and Theory?Minds and Machines, 2015
- Like ripples on a pond: Behavioral spillovers and their implications for research and policyJournal of Economic Psychology, 2015
- Against Autonomy2012
- The Ethics of Nudge2009
- Psychological reactance and the attractiveness of unobtainable objects: Sex differences in children's responses to an elimination of freedomSex Roles, 1981