A comparison of line‐transect distance sampling methods for estimating gopher tortoise population densities
- 5 December 2015
- journal article
- tools and-technology
- Published by Wiley in Wildlife Society Bulletin
- Vol. 39 (4) , 804-812
Abstract
Line‐transect distance sampling (LTDS) is increasingly used to estimate gopher tortoise ( Gopherus polyphemus ) densities. The process requires detecting tortoise burrows, and then determining occupancy. We compared 3 LTDS approaches that differ in how burrow detection and occupancy data are integrated, and 2 search strategies. Surveys were conducted at Avon Park Air Force Range in South‐central Florida, USA, from April through October 2009. These include 1) LTDS using data from occupied burrows only; 2) LTDS with burrows treated as “clusters” of size 1 or 0 depending on occupancy; 3) LTDS to estimate burrow densities, with occupancy modeling to estimate occupancy rates; and 4) 2 search strategies: standard versus expanded searches. The LTDS method produced reliable burrow density estimates, and tortoise densities were estimated most precisely and with least effort using data from occupied burrows only. However, any method could be biased if burrow occupancy is uncertain. Indeed, in the Florida scrub and pine flatwoods habitats, video‐camera scoping was hindered by groundwater or obstructions, resulting in undetermined occupancy for 45% of burrows. Improving scope technologies and surveying during the dry season has improved subsequent results for xeric habitats; however, research is needed to improve detectability of tortoises in mesic habitats with flooded burrows. If occupancy is uncertain, we recommend collecting data on all burrows, irrespective of occupancy, so that burrow densities can be estimated even if occupancy cannot. We do not recommend expanding the search area with sigmoid search paths adjacent to transects owing to potential violations of assumptions, nor use of occupancy modeling, because model requirements may lead to unacceptable exclusion of data. © 2015 The Wildlife Society.Keywords
Funding Information
- U.S. Air Force under Cooperative Agreement (W81XWH-06-2-0026)
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Estimating abundance and population trends when detection is low and highly variable: A comparison of three methods for the Hermann's tortoiseThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2013
- Gopher Tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus) Burrow Densities in Scrub and Flatwoods Habitats of Peninsular FloridaChelonian Conservation and Biology, 2012
- Evidence for and geomorphologic consequences of a reptilian ecosystem engineer: The burrowing cascade initiated by the Gopher TortoiseGeomorphology, 2012
- Detecting trends in desert tortoise population growth: elusive behavior inflates variance in estimates of population densityEndangered Species Research, 2009
- IMPROVING ESTIMATES OF BIRD DENSITY USING MULTIPLE- COVARIATE DISTANCE SAMPLINGOrnithology, 2007
- Modeling the Probability of Resource Use: The Effect of, and Dealing with, Detecting a Species ImperfectlyThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2006
- PROBLEMS WITH SAMPLING DESERT TORTOISES: A SIMULATION ANALYSIS BASED ON FIELD DATAThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2005
- Field Trials of Line Transect Methods Applied to Estimation of Desert Tortoise AbundanceThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2001
- Gopher Tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus) Densities in Coastal Scrub and Slash Pine Flatwoods in FloridaJournal of Herpetology, 1994
- Estimating Occupancy of Gopher Tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus) Burrows in Coastal Scrub and Slash Pine FlatwoodsJournal of Herpetology, 1991