Comparison of Bovine and Porcine Collagen Membranes for Potential Applications in Guided Bone Regeneration: An In Vivo Pre‐Clinical Evaluation
Authors:
- 22 September 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials
- Vol. 113 (10) , e35651
Abstract
In an effort to improve bone response, predictably regenerate lost tissue, and provide an anatomically pleasing ridge contour for biomechanically favorable and prosthetically driven implant placement, guided bone regeneration (GBR) procedures have been indicated. This study provides the first direct in vivo comparison of the biocompatibility of an experimental porcine‐derived collagen membrane (CMI, Regenity Biosciences, Paramus, NJ, USA) and a commercially available bovine‐derived collagen membrane (CopiOs, ZimVie, Palm Beach Gardens, FL, USA) in a beagle mandibular model for the purposes of GBR. Four bilateral defects of 10 mm × 10 mm through the mandibular thickness were placed in each of n = 16 adult beagle dogs. Defects were filled with a deproteinized porcine‐derived particulate graft and were covered either with CMI or CopiOs to allow compartmentalized healing. Animals were euthanized after 4, 8, 12, or 16 weeks post‐operatively ( n = 4 beagles /time point). Bone regenerative capacity, graft, and soft tissue presence were evaluated by histomorphometric and microtomographic analyses. Outcome variables were compared using a mixed model analysis with fixed factor variables of time and material. Qualitatively, no histomorphological differences in healing were observed between the membrane groups at any time point. Histomorphometrically, CMI and CopiOs presented statistically significant differences in bone (mean ± SD: 38.27% ± 15.20 vs. 17.43% ± 15.49, respectively, p = 0.016) and soft tissue presence (mean ± SD: 50.88% ± 11.83 vs. 68.21% ± 16.98, respectively, p = 0.026) at 8 weeks. These results might influence treatment timing in clinical practice, by enabling early implant placement or shorter healing intervals. No significant differences were detected in these parameters at any other healing time point ( p > 0.05). CMI and CopiOs showed no signs of adverse immune response and led to similar trends in bone regeneration after 16 weeks of permitted healing. Both membranes minimized soft tissue infiltration and maintained defect stability over the observed healing periods without adverse events such as inflammation and/or foreign body reaction.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Osteogenic differentiation and reconstruction of mandible defects using a novel resorbable membrane: An in vitro and in vivo experimental studyJournal of Biomedical Materials Research Part B: Applied Biomaterials, 2023
- Comparative barrier membrane degradation over time: Pericardium versus dermal membranesClinical and Experimental Dental Research, 2021
- Membranes for Guided Bone Regeneration: A Road from Bench to BedsideAdvanced Healthcare Materials, 2020
- Guided Bone Regeneration in Alveolar Bone ReconstructionOral and Maxillofacial Surgery Clinics of North America, 2019
- Treatment of Labial Soft Tissue Recession Around Dental Implants in the Esthetic Zone Using Guided Bone Regeneration With Mineralized Allograft: A Retrospective Clinical Case SeriesJournal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 2016
- Current barrier membranes: Titanium mesh and other membranes for guided bone regeneration in dental applicationsJournal of Prosthodontic Research, 2013
- Recent advances in the development of GTR/GBR membranes for periodontal regeneration—A materials perspectiveDental Materials, 2012
- Success rate of dental implants inserted in horizontal and vertical guided bone regenerated areas: a systematic reviewInternational Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, 2012
- Immune responses to implants – A review of the implications for the design of immunomodulatory biomaterialsBiomaterials, 2011
- Polymeric membranes for guided bone regenerationBiotechnology Journal, 2011