City diplomacy and “glocal” governance: revitalizing cosmopolitan democracy
- 9 March 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research
- Vol. 29 (2) , 134-160
Abstract
Diplomacy is in trouble. With globalization come global problems. While we live in a twenty-first-century world of interdependence, we face seventeenth-century Westphalian political institutions with defined boundaries and separated responsibilities of nation-states. When we think of diplomacy, we are thinking of state-to-state relations; however, with sovereign obligation and national interest obsession, state-to-state negotiations often fall into “gridlocks”; international policy-making also suffers from “democratic deficits”. David Held offered cosmopolitan democracy as the answer, but his “world government” thesis provides no realistic policy implications. In very recent years, city-to-city (“trans-municipal”) networks have received significant international recognition as cities are able to cooperate, with concrete actions, on a range of global issues. Surprisingly, scholars of international relations have largely neglected the role of cities in global governance. This paper argues for city diplomacy and “glocal” governance to fill the theoretical gap. It has two purposes: (1) to break the “conceptual jail” of regarding nation-states as the legitimate subject to manage world affairs, and open the door for cities and (2) to revisit the condition of cosmopolitan democracy, and offer a realistic model to revitalize the concept while bypassing the infeasibility of world government. In Part I, as I revisit Confucian philosophy da-tong (great unity), Rosenau's “sovereignty-free” actors and Athenian democracy, I argue that cities are our best hope to transcend nationality for the common well-being of humanity, connect local citizens to global public policy, and move towards cosmopolitan democracy. In Part II, drawing on Dahl's democratic criteria and DeBúrca's “democratic-striving approach”, I will develop two “building blocks” of democracy at the global level – —equal participation and popular control. In Part III, with reference to the “building blocks”, I will conduct a qualitative analysis to evaluate the cosmopolitan characteristics of C40 and develop political justifications for “trans-municipal networks”.Keywords
Funding Information
- Chevening Scholarship of the UK Foreign and Commonwealth Office (HKCV - 2014 - 1468)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Global governance and democratic legitimacy: a bottom-up approachInnovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 2013
- Democracy and global governance: the case for a bottom-up and context-sensitive approachInnovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 2013
- Inequality in new global governance arrangements: the North–South divide in transnational municipal networksInnovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 2013
- Global governance and legitimacyReview of International Political Economy, 2011
- Governing from the middle: the C40 Cities Leadership GroupCorporate Governance: The international journal of business in society, 2010
- Restructuring Global Governance: Cosmopolitanism, Democracy and the Global OrderMillennium: Journal of International Studies, 2009
- What is Globalization?2007
- Accountability in World Politics1Scandinavian Political Studies, 2006
- Patrolling the ‘frontier’: Globalization, localization and the ‘actorness’ of non‐central governmentsRegional & Federal Studies, 1999
- Lazarus Spengler, Christoph Kress, and Nuremberg's Reformation DiplomacyThe Sixteenth Century Journal, 1974