Evaluating the Quality of Open Building Datasets for Mapping Urban Inequality: A Comparative Analysis Across 5 Cities
Preprint
Abstract
While informal settlements lack focused development and are highly dynamic, the quality of spatial data for these places may be uncertain. This study evaluates the quality and biases of AI-generated Open Building Datasets (OBDs) generated by Google and Microsoft against OpenStreetMap (OSM) data, across diverse global cities including Accra, Nairobi, Caracas, Berlin, and Houston. The Intersection over Union (IoU), overlap analysis and a positional accuracy algorithm are used to analyse the similarity and alignment of the datasets. The paper also analyses the size distribution of the building polygon area, and completeness using predefined but regular spatial units. The results indicate significant variance in data quality, with Houston and Berlin demonstrating high alignment and completeness, reflecting their structured urban environments. There are gaps in the datasets analysed, and cities like Accra and Caracas may be under-represented. This could highlight difficulties in capturing complex or informal regions. The study also notes different building size distributions, which may be indicative of the global socio-economic divide. These findings may emphasise the need to consider the quality of global building datasets to avoid misrepresentation, which is an important element of planning and resource distribution.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 79 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quality of crowdsourced geospatial building information: A global assessment of OpenStreetMap attributesBuilding and Environment, 2023
- Building footprint extraction and counting on very high-resolution satellite imagery using object detection deep learning frameworkEarth Science Informatics, 2022
- First-Class but not for Long: Heterogeneous Infrastructure and Water Bricolage in Accra’s Kiosk CompoundsUrban Forum, 2021
- Demographic drivers of Norway rat populations from urban slums in BrazilUrban Ecosystems, 2020
- What Is Deep Learning?2019
- Solutions for Data Quality in GIS and VGI: A Systematic Literature Review2019
- A System of Innovation to Activate Practices on Open Data: The Open4Citizens Project2018
- The morphology of the Arrival City - A global categorization based on literature surveys and remotely sensed dataApplied Geography, 2018
- Open Government Data Ecosystems: Linking Transparency for Innovation with Transparency for Participation and Accountability2016
- Transverse Mercator with an accuracy of a few nanometersJournal of Geodesy, 2011