Avoiding skull radiographs in infants with suspected inflicted injury who also undergo head CT: “a no-brainer?”
Open Access
- 3 December 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Radiology
- Vol. 30 (3) , 1480-1487
Abstract
Objectives: To assess whether head CT with 3D reconstruction can replace skull radiographs (SXR) in the imaging investigation of suspected physical abuse (SPA)/abusive head trauma (AHT). Methods: PACS was interrogated for antemortem skeletal surveys performed for SPA, patients younger than 2 years, SXR and CT performed within 4 days of each other. Paired SXR and CT were independently reviewed. One reviewer analysed CT without and (3 months later) with 3D reconstructions. SXR and CT expert consensus review formed the gold standard. Observer reliability was calculated. Results: A total of 104 SXR/CT examination pairs were identified, mean age 6.75 months (range 4 days to 2 years); 21 (20%) had skull fractures; two fractures on CT were missed on SXR. There were no fractures on SXR that were not seen on CT. For SXR and CT, respectively: PPV reviewer 1, 95% confidence interval (CI) 48–82% and 85–100%; reviewer 2, 67–98% and 82–100%; and NPV reviewer 1, 95%, CI 88–98% and 96–100%; reviewer 2, 88–97% and 88–98%. Inter- and intra-observer reliability were respectively the following: SXR, excellent (kappa = 0.831) and good (kappa = 0.694); CT, excellent (kappa = 0.831) and perfect (kappa = 1). All results were statistically significant (p < 0.001). Conclusions: CT has greater diagnostic accuracy than SXR in detecting skull fractures which is increased on concurrent review of 3D reconstructions and should be performed in every case of SPA/AHT. SXR does not add further diagnostic information and can be omitted from the skeletal survey when CT with 3D reconstruction is going to be, or has been, performed. Key Points: • Head CT with 3D reconstruction is more sensitive and specific for the diagnosis of skull fractures. • Skull radiographs can be safely omitted from the initial skeletal survey performed for suspected physical abuse when head CT with 3D reconstruction is going to be, or has been, performed.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Sheffield
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- The neuroimaging mimics of abusive head traumaEuropean Journal of Paediatric Neurology, 2019
- Head imaging in suspected non accidental injury in the paediatric population. In the advent of volumetric CT imaging, has the skull X-ray become redundant?Clinical Radiology, 2018
- Reappraisal of Neonatal Greenstick Skull Fractures Caused by Birth Injuries: Comparison of 3-Dimensional Reconstructed Computed Tomography and Simple Skull RadiographsWorld Neurosurgery, 2018
- Reappraisal of Pediatric Diastatic Skull Fractures in the 3-Dimensional CT Era: Clinical Characteristics and Comparison of Diagnostic Accuracy of Simple Skull X-Ray, 2-Dimensional CT, and 3-Dimensional CTWorld Neurosurgery, 2017
- Performance of computed tomography of the head to evaluate for skull fractures in infants with suspected non-accidental traumaPediatric Radiology, 2016
- Pediatric skull fracture diagnosis: should 3D CT reconstructions be added as routine imaging?Journal of neurosurgery. Pediatrics, 2015
- ESPR adopts British guidelines for imaging in suspected non-accidental injury as the European standardPediatric Radiology, 2014
- Descriptive factors of abusive head trauma in young children—United States, 2000–2009Child Abuse & Neglect, 2013
- Shaken baby syndrome in New Zealand, 2000–2002Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, 2007
- Late Neurologic and Cognitive Sequelae of Inflicted Traumatic Brain Injury in InfancyPediatrics, 2005