Impact of analytic decisions on test-retest reliability of individual and group estimates in functional magnetic resonance imaging: a multiverse analysis using the monetary incentive delay task
Preprint
Abstract
Empirical studies reporting low test-retest reliability of individual blood oxygen-level dependent (BOLD) signal estimates in functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data have resurrected interest among cognitive neuroscientists in methods that may improve reliability in fMRI. Over the last decade, several individual studies have reported that modeling decisions, such as smoothing, motion correction and contrast selection, may improve estimates of test-retest reliability of BOLD signal estimates. However, it remains an empirical question whether certain analytic decisions consistently improve individual and group level reliability estimates in an fMRI task across multiple large, independent samples. This study used three independent samples ( N s: 60, 81, 119) that collected the same task (Monetary Incentive Delay task) across two runs and two sessions to evaluate the effects of analytic decisions on the individual (intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC(3,1)]) and group (Jaccard/Spearman rho ) reliability estimates of BOLD activity of task fMRI data. The analytic decisions in this study vary across four categories: smoothing kernel (five options), motion correction (four options), task parameterizing (three options) and task contrasts (four options), totaling 240 different pipeline permutations. Across all 240 pipelines, the median ICC estimates are consistently low, with a maximum median ICC estimate of .43 - .55 across the three samples. The analytic decisions with the greatest impact on the median ICC and group similarity estimates are the Implicit Baseline contrast, Cue Model parameterization and a larger smoothing kernel. Using an Implicit Baseline in a contrast condition meaningfully increased group similarity and ICC estimates as compared to using the Neutral cue. This effect was largest for the Cue Model parameterization; however, improvements in reliability came at the cost of interpretability. This study illustrates that estimates of reliability in the MID task are consistently low and variable at small samples, and a higher test-retest reliability may not always improve interpretability of the estimated BOLD signal.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Imaging Neuroscience, 2.
This publication has 90 references indexed in Scilit:
- Isolating the sources of pipeline‐variability in group‐level task‐fMRI resultsHuman Brain Mapping, 2021
- Influence of sample size and analytic approach on stability and interpretation of brain‐behavior correlations in task‐related fMRI dataHuman Brain Mapping, 2020
- The Neural Substrate of Reward Anticipation in Health: A Meta-Analysis of fMRI Findings in the Monetary Incentive Delay TaskNeuropsychology Review, 2018
- Intraclass correlation: Improved modeling approaches and applications for neuroimagingHuman Brain Mapping, 2017
- Association of Marijuana Use With Blunted Nucleus Accumbens Response to Reward AnticipationJAMA Psychiatry, 2016
- Sample size requirements for estimating intraclass correlations with desired precisionStatistics in Medicine, 2002
- Baseline conditions and subtractive logic in neuroimagingHuman Brain Mapping, 2001
- FMRI Visualization of Brain Activity during a Monetary Incentive Delay TaskNeuroImage, 2000
- Cognitive Conjunction: A New Approach to Brain Activation ExperimentsNeuroImage, 1997
- An Overview of Psychological Measurement1978