The Exclusion Controversy, Pamphleteering, and Locke's Two Treatises
Author:
- 1 March 1981
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Historical Journal
- Vol. 24 (1) , 49-68
Abstract
It is now more than twenty years since Peter Laslett argued that the Exclusion controversy and not the Revolution of 1688 was the occasion of the composition of Locke's Two treatises. Nevertheless, scholarly interpretations still resist treating Two treatises as mainly an activist tract and persist in characterizing it always as something loftier, viz. ‘political philosophy’, ‘systematic moral apologia’, and the like. Resistance to the implications of a rigorous historical mode of interpretation is surely part of the problem. The perennial or transcendent purposes with which the classics are haloed often get diminished in too specific an historical location of the motives and situation of the author. Oddly, however, even critics friendly to a strictly historical approach have hesitated before the implications of Laslett's dicta that Locke wrote as a whig pamphleteer and for Shaftesbury's purposes. This, in turn, parallels the widespread contempt felt by many contemporary English historians (Locke's interpreters among them) for the early whigs. Righteous indignation against the whigs is even detectable in those modern writings from which we take our view of the whig Exclusion pamphleteers.Keywords
This publication has 2 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Idea of Conquest in Controversies Over the 1688 RevolutionJournal of the History of Ideas, 1977
- II. The Whig Exclusionists: Pamphlet Literature in the Exclusion Campaign, 1679–81Cambridge Historical Journal, 1957