Going high and low: on pluralism and neutrality in human embryology policy-making
- 8 December 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 50 (12) , 846-854
Abstract
Formulating sound and acceptable embryo research policy remains challenging especially in a pluralistic world. This challenge has acquired a new dimension of complexity with the advent of so-called embryo models, which are derived from stem cells. In this article, we present a normative strategy to facilitate the process of sound policy-making in the field of human embryology. This strategy involves seeking neutral agreements on higher level theories and doctrines as well as seeking agreements on the level of concrete policy proposals. We call this strategy: going high and low. By going high and low, the plurality of reasonable moral and epistemic convictions of stakeholders involved in the domain of human embryology is respected while the process of policy-making in this area is improved.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Embryology policy: Revisit the 14-day ruleNature, 2016
- The science, policy, and ethics of stem cell researchReproductive BioMedicine Online, 2007
- THE MORAL STATUS OF STEM CELLSMetaphilosophy, 2007
- The Nonindividuation Argument Against Zygotic PersonhoodPhilosophy, 2006
- More than Modus Vivendi, less than Overlapping Consensus: towards a Political Theory of Social CompromiseSocial Science Information, 2004
- Incompletely Theorized AgreementsHarvard Law Review, 1995
- Pluralism and Reasonable DisagreementSocial Philosophy and Policy, 1994
- Who or What is the Preembryo?Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 1991
- ARGUING FROM POTENTIAL*Bioethics, 1988
- Types of moral argument against embryo researchBioEssays, 1987