Assessing the Impact of Rainfall Inputs on Short-Term Flood Simulation with Cell2Flood: A Case Study of the Waryong Reservoir Basin
Open Access
Abstract
This study explored the impacts of various rainfall input types on short-term runoff simulations using the Cell2Flood model in the Waryong Reservoir Basin, South Korea. Six types of rainfall data were assessed: on-site gauge measurements, spatially interpolated data from 39 Automated Synoptic Observing System (ASOS) and 117 Automatic Weather System (AWS) stations using inverse distance weighting (IDW), and Hybrid Surface Rainfall (HSR) data from the Korea Meteorological Administration. The choice of rainfall input significantly affected model accuracy across the three rainfall events. The point-gauged ASOS (P-ASOS) data demonstrated the highest reliability in capturing the observed rainfall patterns, with Pearson’s r values of up to 0.84, whereas the radar-derived HSR data had the lowest correlations (Pearson’s r below 0.2), highlighting substantial discrepancies. For runoff simulation, the P-ASOS and ASOS-AWS combined interpolated dataset (R-AWS) achieved relatively accurate predictions, with P-ASOS and R-AWS exhibiting Normalized Peak Error (NPE) values of approximately 0.03 and Peak Time Error (PTE) within 20 min. In contrast, the HSR data produced large errors, with NPE up to 4.66 and PTE deviations exceeding 200 min, indicating poor temporal accuracy. Although input-specific calibration improved performance, significant errors persisted because of the inherent uncertainty of rainfall data. These findings underscore the importance of selecting and calibrating appropriate rainfall inputs to enhance the reliability of short-term flood modeling, particularly in ungauged and data-sparse basins.Keywords
Funding Information
- Korea Institute of Planning and Evaluation for Technology in Food, Agriculture, and Forestry (iPET) (RS-2022-IP322078)
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Comparative Evaluation of Using Rain Gauge and NEXRAD Radar-Estimated Rainfall Data for Simulating StreamflowHydrology, 2022
- A critical review of real-time modelling of flood forecasting in urban drainage systemsJournal of Hydrology, 2022
- The Role of the Spatial Distribution of Radar Rainfall on Hydrological Modeling for an Urbanized River Basin in JapanWater, 2019
- Estimation of Storm-Centred Areal Reduction Factors from Radar Rainfall for Design in Urban HydrologyWater, 2019
- Evaluation and comparison of interpolated gauge rainfall data and gridded rainfall data in Florida, USAHydrological Sciences Journal, 2018
- Impact of land use change on hydrological systems: A review of current modeling approachesCogent Geoscience, 2015
- Inter-comparison of radar rainfall rate using Constant Altitude Plan Position Indicator and hybrid surface rainfall mapsJournal of Hydrology, 2015
- Distributed Hydrologic Prediction: Sensitivity to Accuracy of Initial Soil Moisture Conditions and Radar Rainfall InputJournal of Hydrologic Engineering, 2009
- Rainfall input requirements for hydrological calculationsUrban Water, 2001
- A coupled rainfall-runoff and runoff-routing model for adaptive real-time flood forecastingWater Resources Management, 1991