A priori tests of eddy viscosity models in square duct flow
Open Access
- 31 July 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics
- Vol. 34 (5-6) , 713-734
Abstract
We carry out a priori tests of linear and nonlinear eddy viscosity models using direct numerical simulation (DNS) data of square duct flow up to friction Reynolds number $${\text {Re}}_\tau =1055$$ . We focus on the ability of eddy viscosity models to reproduce the anisotropic Reynolds stress tensor components $$a_{ij}$$ responsible for turbulent secondary flows, namely the normal stress $$a_{22}$$ and the secondary shear stress $$a_{23}$$ . A priori tests on constitutive relations for $$a_{ij}$$ are performed using the tensor polynomial expansion of Pope (J Fluid Mech 72:331–340, 1975), whereby one tensor base corresponds to the linear eddy viscosity hypothesis and five bases return exact representation of $$a_{ij}$$ . We show that the bases subset has an important effect on the accuracy of the stresses and the best results are obtained when using tensor bases which contain both the strain rate and the rotation rate. Models performance is quantified using the mean correlation coefficient with respect to DNS data $${\widetilde{C}}_{ij}$$ , which shows that the linear eddy viscosity hypothesis always returns very accurate values of the primary shear stress $$a_{12}$$ ( $${\widetilde{C}}_{12}>0.99$$ ), whereas two bases are sufficient to achieve good accuracy of the normal stress and secondary shear stress ( $${\widetilde{C}}_{22}=0.911$$ , $${\widetilde{C}}_{23}=0.743$$ ). Unfortunately, RANS models rely on additional assumptions and a priori analysis carried out on popular models, includingk– $$\varepsilon $$ and $$v^2$$ –f, reveals that none of them achieves ideal accuracy. The only model based on Pope’s expansion which approaches ideal performance is the quadratic correction of Spalart (Int J Heat Fluid Flow 21:252–263, 2000), which has similar accuracy to models using four or more tensor bases. Nevertheless, the best results are obtained when using the linear correction to the $$v^2$$ –fmodel developed by Pecnik and Iaccarino (AIAA Paper 2008-3852, 2008), although this is not built on the canonical tensor polynomial as the other models.
Keywords
Funding Information
- Delft University of Technology
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Turbulent FlowsMeasurement Science and Technology, 2001
- Strategies for turbulence modelling and simulationsInternational Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 2000
- General explicit algebraic stress relations and best approximation for three-dimensional flowsInternational Journal of Engineering Science, 1998
- Development and application of a cubic eddy-viscosity model of turbulenceInternational Journal of Heat and Fluid Flow, 1996
- Separated flow computations with the k-epsilon-v-squared modelAIAA Journal, 1995
- On explicit algebraic stress models for complex turbulent flowsJournal of Fluid Mechanics, 1993
- Prediction of Anisotropy of the Near-Wall Turbulence With an Anisotropic Low-Reynolds-Number k–ε Turbulence ModelJournal of Fluids Engineering, 1990
- On nonlinear K-l and K-ε models of turbulenceJournal of Fluid Mechanics, 1987
- Turbulent channel and Couette flows using an anisotropic k-epsilon modelAIAA Journal, 1987
- On turbulent secondary flows in pipes of noncircular cross-sectionInternational Journal of Engineering Science, 1982