Abstract
We introduce an Alchemical Transfer Method (ATM) protocol based on the transfer of a ligand-water adduct to estimate the relative binding free energy (RBFE) between two congeneric ligands that differ by substituents and the number of bound water molecules. The approach targets RBFE applications aimed at estimating the effect of displacing a bridging water molecule on the binding strength. While important, these cases are not easily handled by conventional RBFE protocols when the bound water molecule is kinetically trapped. These difficulties are circumvented in the proposed Water Transfer Alchemical Transfer Method (WT-RBFE) because the target water molecule is transferred in and out of the binding site together with the ligand it is bound to. The present work introduces an extension of the conventional ATM-RBFE protocol similar in spirit and equivalent to recently developed methods based on water coupling and decoupling. We test the method on a protein-ligand benchmark set previously used to validate water displacement and water sampling algorithms in alchemical binding applications, and we show that it produces more accurate, reliable, and reproducible RBFE predictions than standard approaches.