Same Problem, Different Policies
Open Access
- 1 June 2019
- journal article
- Published by IU Indianapolis University Library in Advances in Social Work
- Vol. 19 (1) , 39-61
Abstract
Educators teaching policy analysis can choose from many available frameworks, varying in purpose and approach. These frameworks typically advise students to view policies as transient and context-sensitive, but to view the problems activating the policies as objective and static conditions. How problems are variably framed in policy relative to how students are advised to analyze them has not captured the profession’s interest. This article presents 1) an overview of policy analysis frameworks; 2) a summary of findings from a recent study investigating how social policy texts advise students to analyze problems and; 3) a social constructionist framework (matrix) that provides an historical and contextual view of social problems and policy responses. This Problem-to-Policy framework corrects the omissions in most frameworks by including the forces that contributed to a problem’s discovery and construction, while also identifying periods of silence when the problem endured yet faded from view. The author argues that this framework bolsters policy practice by 1) emphasizing those problem frames and contexts that historically led to progressive policies and 2) underscores the urgency for social workers to engage with affected populations in the initial (re)claiming and (re)framing of problems, rather than during the later policy-making stages when constructions have already presaged policy responses.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- When They Return: Framing the Argument for InclusionJournal of Human Rights and Social Work, 2018
- Measuring interest group framing strategies in public policy debatesJournal of Public Policy, 2015
- Feminist Policy Analysis: Expanding Traditional Social Work MethodsJournal of Teaching in Social Work, 2013
- Alcohol Use and Policy Formation: An Evolving Social ProblemSocial Work in Public Health, 2012
- Organizational Responses to Social Policy: The Case of Welfare ReformAdministration in Social Work, 2010
- Unraveling the Social Construction of HomelessnessJournal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment, 2010
- Same Words, Different Meanings: Notes Toward a Typology of Postmodern Social Work EducationSocial Work Education, 2008
- Constructing meaning: Strengthening the policy-practice linkSocial Work Education, 2002
- Constructivism: An approach to clinical practice∗Smith College Studies in Social Work, 1993
- Modern history of child sexual abuse awareness: Cycles of discovery and suppressionChild Abuse & Neglect, 1993