Fetal death certificate data quality: A tale of two US counties
Authors:
- Lauren Christiansen-LindquistLCLauren Christiansen-Lindquist
- Robert M. SilverRSRobert M. Silver
- Corette B. ParkerCPCorette B. Parker
- Donald J. DudleyDDDonald J. Dudley
- Matthew A. KochMKMatthew A. Koch
- Uma M. ReddyURUma M. Reddy
- George R. SaadeGSGeorge R. Saade
- Robert L. GoldenbergRGRobert L. Goldenberg
- Carol J. R. HogueCHCarol J. R. Hogue
Preprint
Abstract
Purpose: Describe the relative frequency and joint effect of missing and misreported fetal death certificate (FDC) data and identify variations by key characteristics. Methods: Stillbirths were prospectively identified during 2006-2008 for a multi-site population-based case-control study. For this study, eligible mothers of stillbirths were not incarcerated residents of DeKalb County, Georgia, or Salt Lake County, Utah, aged > 13 years, with an identifiable FDC. We identified the frequency of missing and misreported (any departure from the study value) FDC data by county, race/ethnicity, gestational age, and whether the stillbirth was antepartum or intrapartum. Results: Data quality varied by item, and was highest in Salt Lake County. Reporting was generally not associated with maternal or delivery characteristics. Reasons for poor data quality varied by item in DeKalb County: some items were frequently missing and misreported; however, others were of poor quality due to either missing or misreported data. Conclusions: FDC data suffer from missing and inaccurate data, with variations by item and county. Salt Lake County data illustrate that high quality reporting is attainable. The overall quality of reporting must be improved to support consequential epidemiologic analyses for stillbirth, and improvement efforts should be tailored to the needs of each jurisdiction. Abbreviations and Acronyms: CCC concordance correlation coefficient CDC Centers for Disease Control and Prevention FDC Fetal death certificate NCHS National Center for Health Statistics SCRN Stillbirth Collaborative Research NetworkKeywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Annals of Epidemiology, 27 (8), 466.
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Implications for Improving Fetal Death Vital Statistics: Connecting Reporters’ Self-Identified Practices and Barriers to Third Trimester Fetal Death Data Quality in New York CityMaternal and Child Health Journal, 2015
- Understanding Perinatal Death: A Systematic Analysis of New York City Fetal and Neonatal Death Vital Record Data and Implications for Improvement, 2007–2011Maternal and Child Health Journal, 2014
- Correlation Between Stillbirth Vital Statistics and Medical RecordsObstetrics & Gynecology, 2010
- Using active birth defects surveillance programs to supplement data on fetal death reports: Improving surveillance data on stillbirthsBirth Defects Research Part A: Clinical and Molecular Teratology, 2008
- Fetal Death Certificates as a Source of Surveillance Data for Stillbirths with Birth DefectsPublic Health Reports®, 2007
- Validity of Maternal and Perinatal Risk Factors Reported on Fetal Death CertificatesAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2005
- The role of linked birth and infant death certificates in maternal and child health epidemiology in the United StatesAmerican Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2000
- Quality assessment of fetal death records in Georgia: a method for improvement.American Journal of Public Health, 1997
- Accuracy of fetal death reports: comparison with data from an independent stillbirth assessment program.American Journal of Public Health, 1987
- A comparative study of hospital fetal death records and Washington State fetal death certificates.American Journal of Public Health, 1986