Comparison of 2D and 3D multichannel audio rendering methods for hearing research applications using technical and perceptual measures
Open Access
- 1 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by EDP Sciences in Acta Acustica
- Vol. 8, 17
Abstract
Virtual reality with multichannel audio playback is increasingly used in hearing aid research. The purpose of this study is to compare horizontal (2D) and periphonic (3D) rendering methods in terms of localization, minimum audible angle, and perceptual ratings related to spatial quality. Higher Order Ambisonics, Vector-Base Amplitude Panning, and Nearest Speaker Selection were used, with playback through 16, 29 and 45 speakers. The results show that an improvement in vertical localization can be obtained by using periphonic rendering instead of horizontal rendering. The perceptual advantage of periphonic rendering depends on the spatial complexity of the scene; it disappears in complex acoustic environments. Scenes with low acoustic complexity, such as a single primary sound source in a room, benefit from Nearest Speaker Selection rendering. For more complex scenes with multiple sound sources, such as a symphony orchestra in a concert hall with many primary sources, or traffic on a road with moving sources, horizontal rendering methods such as 2D Higher Order Ambisonics will provide similar or better performance.Keywords
Funding Information
- Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (Project-ID 352015383 – SFB 1330 B1/A5)
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Measuring and modeling speech intelligibility in real and loudspeaker-based virtual sound environmentsHearing Research, 2019
- Virtual acoustic environments for comprehensive evaluation of model-based hearing devicesInternational Journal of Audiology, 2016
- Spatial Sound With Loudspeakers and Its Perception: A Review of the Current StateProceedings of the IEEE, 2013
- 3D soundfield reproduction using higher order loudspeakers2013
- Auditory model based direction estimation of concurrent speakers from binaural signalsSpeech Communication, 2011
- A system to simulate and reproduce audio–visual environments for spatial hearing researchHearing Research, 2010
- Multichannel Sound Reproduction2008
- Circulant and elliptic feedback delay networks for artificial reverberationIEEE Transactions on Speech and Audio Processing, 1997
- Factors That Influence the Localization of Sound in the Vertical PlaneThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 1968
- On the Minimum Audible AngleThe Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 1958