Urbanization is a critical anthropogenic process with largely irreversible effects on the Earth’s surface. However, the implications of future urbanization for other land-dependent systems, through changes in land availability and prices, remain poorly understood, largely due to simplified modeling assumptions and static urbanization constraints. Here, we quantify the impacts of urban land dynamics with a factorial scenario design combined with enhancements to a global multisectoral economic equilibrium model. We simulate divergent scenarios combining urbanization pathways, socioeconomic changes, and bioenergy deployment levels. Across all scenarios, global changes in non-urban land types by 2100 are almost twice as large as urban land changes. This is because managed land losses from urbanization are offset by expansions elsewhere or increased investment in yield-enhancing technologies or higher imports. These changes can increase crop prices, with some regions seeing up to a 20% increase. These results show that urban land expansion can have an indirect footprint that is much higher and beyond the physically urbanized area.