Multiple choice questions are superior to extended matching questions to identify medicine and biomedical sciences students who perform poorly
Open Access
- 11 July 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in Perspectives on Medical Education
- Vol. 2 (5-6) , 252-263
Abstract
In recent years, medical faculties at Dutch universities have implemented a legally binding study advice to students of medicine and biomedical sciences during their propaedeutic phase. Appropriate examination is essential to discriminate between poor (grade <6), moderate (grade 6–8) and excellent (grade ≥8) students. Therefore, we compared the discriminatory properties of extended matching questions (EMQs) versus multiple-choice questions (MCQs) and identified the role of sex, age and examination preference on this score. Data were collected for 452 first-year medical and biomedical science students during three distinct course examinations: one examination with EMQ only, one with MCQ only and one mixed examination (including EMQ and MCQ). Logistic regression analysis revealed that MCQ examination was 3 times better in identifying poor students compared with EMQ (RR 3.0, CI 2.0–4.5), whereas EMQ better detected excellent students (average grade ≥8) (RR 1.93, CI 1.47–2.53). Mixed examination had comparable characteristics to MCQ. Sex and examination preference did not impact the score of the student. Students ≥20 years had a 4-fold higher risk ratio of obtaining a poor grade (<6) compared with students ≤18 years old (RR 4.1, CI 2.1–8.0). Given the strong discriminative capacity of MCQ examinations to identify poor students, we recommend the use of this type of examination during the propaedeutic phase of medicine and biomedical science study programmes, in the light of the binding study advice.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do extended matching multiple‐choice questions measure clinical reasoning?Medical Education, 2005
- A Note on Multiple Choice Exams, with Respect to Students' Risk Preference and ConfidenceAssessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 2001
- A Multiple Choice Test that Rewards Partial KnowledgeJournal of Further and Higher Education, 2001
- Multiple‐choice examinations: adopting an evidence‐based approach to exam techniqueAnaesthesia, 1998
- Predictors of performance at business school and beyondJournal of Management Development, 1997
- Comparison of items in five-option and extended-matching formats for assessment of diagnostic skillsAcademic Medicine, 1994
- To Guess or Not to Guess: A Decision‐Theoretic View of Formula ScoringJournal of Educational Measurement, 1993
- Extended‐matching items: A practical alternative to free‐response questionsTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 1993
- THE MULTIPLE-CHOICE TESTNurse Educator, 1989
- The Correction for GuessingReview of Educational Research, 1973