Linking Survivor Stories to Forensic Engineering: How an Interscience Approach Reveals Opportunities for Reducing Tornado Vulnerability in Residential Structures
- 1 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Meteorological Society in Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society
- Vol. 105 (8) , E1521-E1541
Abstract
When a tornado strikes a permanent or mobile/manufactured home, occupants are at risk of injury and death from blunt force trauma caused by debris-loaded winds and failure of the structure. Mechanisms for these failures have been studied for the past few decades and identified common weaknesses in the structural load path. Also under study in recent decades, much has been learned about how people receive and understand warnings and determine how, when, and if they will shelter in advance. Recent research, for example, shows most people do not shelter until close to impact, after seeing, hearing, or feeling the approaching tornado. To advance beyond these innovations, a new, multidisciplinary approach was fielded in nine southeast U.S. tornadoes between 2019 and 2022. For each tornado, 1) wind engineering assessments documented near-surface wind fields, 2) structural engineering assessments documented the primary wind load path for each structure, and 3) social science interviews captured the survivor’s narrative and asked several follow-up questions to assure key items of interest were addressed in each interview. When possible, the team was multidisciplinary during the interview, enabling survivors to ask questions and better understand their experiences. Most survivors became aware of the approaching tornado with at least a few minutes of lead time, and most were able to reach a place of refuge. Most survivors recalled sensory experiences during the tornado, and about half could describe the direction or temporal sequences of damage. A case study of the Cookeville, Tennessee, tornado of 3 March 2020 illustrates the power of the integrated data assessment. Significance Statement: Linking an understanding of how tornadic winds interact with residential buildings with how human decisions affect survival has rarely been done due to the inherent complexity and cost of conducting joint social science, forensic engineering, and wind engineering assessments. Such work may reveal ways to reduce the number of injuries and fatalities caused by tornadoes. This study tested a multidisciplinary protocol to holistically evaluate the sheltering and survivability of individual homes for nine southeast U.S. tornadoes. We found many instances where survivors’ stories, photos/videos, and access to structural elements were invaluable for understanding how a tornado interacted with the residence. Future efforts can advance these findings by focusing on severely damaged structures or severe injuries and through the analysis of floor plans.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Public alert and warning system literature review in the USA: identifying research gaps and lessons for practiceNatural Hazards, 2023
- Life-cycle cost and carbon footprint analysis for light-framed residential buildings subjected to tornado hazardJournal of Building Engineering, 2020
- Field research to application: a study of human response to the 2011, Joplin tornado and its impact on alerts and warnings in the USANatural Hazards, 2020
- Mobile home resident evacuation vulnerability and emergency medical service access during tornado events in the Southeast United StatesInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2019
- The effect of providing probabilistic information about a tornado threat on people’s protective actionsNatural Hazards, 2018
- Putting people at the centre of tornado warnings: How perception analysis can cut fatalitiesInternational Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction, 2016
- Implications of the 2011 Tuscaloosa EF4 tornado for shelter and refuge decisionsNatural Hazards, 2014
- Tornado folk science in Alabama and Mississippi in the 27 April 2011 tornado outbreakGeoJournal, 2014
- Tornado warning dissemination and response at a university campusNatural Hazards, 2009
- Tornado shelter-seeking behavior and tornado shelter options among mobile home residents in the United StatesNatural Hazards, 2008