Although a large literature examines consumer demand for credence foods in traditional retail settings, much less is known about how such demand extends to digital marketplaces. This paper investigates how organic and Non-GMO certification labels shape consumer demand in online food retail markets. Using high-frequency, product-level data from the tea and coffee categories on Amazon in the United Kingdom (UK) and the United States (US), I estimate the influence of verified certification labels on product demand and the responsiveness of demand to price changes across heterogeneous products. The results show that organic and Non-GMO beverages command a significant sales premium, averaging approximately 12 percent. This premium varies across the sales distribution, ranging from about 8 percent at the 25th sales quantile to roughly 25 percent at the 75th quantile. Demand for certified beverages is also substantially less price-elastic, suggesting stronger consumer loyalty and greater pricing power for certified products in digital markets. The estimated demand patterns vary systematically across countries (UK vs. US), product types (tea vs. coffee), and seller types (Amazon vs. third-party sellers). Overall, the findings provide new evidence on how credence labels drive product differentiation and pricing strategies in rapidly expanding online food retail markets.