A Transparency Checklist for Theory-Driven Work in Psychology

Authors:

Abstract
In light of the replication crisis and the Open Science Movement, transparency in psychological research has been increasingly recognized as being of key importance for cumulative knowledge gain. Numerous standards and checklists have been developed to improve transparency in reporting (see e.g., Aczel et al., 2019; Schubert et al., 2025). However, most of the available resources focus on methodological and statistical aspects of reporting, leaving the quality of theory development and theory testing largely unaddressed. To help close this gap, we develop a transparency checklist for reporting theoretical and theory-driven work in psychology, covering five main areas: 1) reporting of verbal theories; 2) reporting of formal models; 3) reporting theory evaluations by simulations; 4) reporting theory evaluations by empirical data; 5) reporting theory evaluations by comparison. The checklist is being actively developed in an iterative consensus process, in which sets of quality criteria are proposed, tested, evaluated by a large sample of experts, and then revised. Here, we present version 4 of the checklist, which is based on the input from 92 experts in the field. The checklist may be used to facilitate more precise and transparent reporting of theoretical work and can incentivize the role of theory in psychology when used in review and research assessment processes.