Revisiting the omitted variables argument: Substantive vs. statistical adequacy
Author:
- 1 June 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Economic Methodology
- Vol. 13 (2) , 179-218
Abstract
The problem of omitted variables is commonly viewed as a statistical misspecification issue which renders the inference concerning the influence of X t on yt unreliable, due to the exclusion of certain relevant factors W t . That is, omitting certain potentially important factors W t may confound the influence of X t on yt . The textbook omitted variables argument attempts to assess the seriousness of this unreliability using the sensitivity of the estimator to the inclusion/exclusion of W t , by tracing that effect to the potential bias/inconsistency of . It is argued that the confounding problem is one of substantive inadequacy in so far as the potential error concerns subject‐matter, not statistical, information. Moreover, the textbook argument in terms of the sensitivity of point estimates provides a poor basis for addressing the confounding problem. The paper reframes the omitted variables question into a hypothesis testing problem, supplemented with a post‐data evaluation of inference based on severe testing. It is shown that this testing perspective can deal effectively with assessing the problem of confounding raised by the omitted variables argument. The assessment of the confouding effect using hypothesis testing is related to the conditional independence and faithfulness assumptions of graphical causal modeling.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Methodology in Practice: Statistical Misspecification TestingPhilosophy of Science, 2004
- Causality in Macroeconomics2001
- Error and the Growth of Experimental Knowledge1996
- On theory testing in econometricsJournal of Econometrics, 1995
- Novel Evidence and Severe TestsPhilosophy of Science, 1991
- The simultaneous-equations model revisitedJournal of Econometrics, 1990
- On Rereading Haavelmo: A Retrospective View of Econometric ModelingEconometric Theory, 1989
- Statistical Foundations of Econometric Modelling1986
- Reporting the Fragility of Regression EstimatesReview of Economics and Statistics, 1983
- Theoretical Statistics1974