Understanding Political Agreements and Disagreements: Evidence from the 2022 French Presidential Election
Authors:
- Jerome LangJLJerome Lang
- César A. HidalgoCHCésar A. Hidalgo
Preprint
Abstract
Since the seminal works of Condorcet and Borda, social choice theory has explored how to aggregate individual preferences into collective decisions. Yet, social choice theory has focused primarily on identifying winners in elections involving few candidates, leaving questions about direct participation on multiple issues relatively unexplored. Here we analyze data collected in a direct participation experiment where people built their own government programs using 120 proposals from the candidates of the 2022 French presidential. We find that in this setting it is useful to introduce a measure of "divisiveness," which can be constructed for any voting rule, is orthogonal to them, and helps identify polarizing proposals. We show that divisiveness captures fragmentation across multiple dimensions (sex, age, political orientation, and urban-rural divide) and explore some of its axiomatic properties. These results suggest divisiveness is a relevant aggregate in direct forms of participation.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Chile: web poll sifts policies amid riot, rallies and curfewsNature, 2019
- A Response to Johanne Kübler’s A Review of Zeynep Tufekci – Twitter and Tear Gas: The Power and Fragility of Networked Protest (2017, New Haven: Yale University Press)International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society, 2019
- The Moral Machine experimentNature, 2018
- Elections and Divisiveness: Theory and EvidenceThe Journal of Politics, 2017
- Religion, politics, and support for same-sex marriage in the United States, 1988–2008Social Science Research, 2011
- A Short Introduction to Computational Social Choice2007
- Independence of clones as a criterion for voting rulesSocial Choice and Welfare, 1987
- A Difficulty in the Concept of Social WelfareJournal of Political Economy, 1950
- The method of paired comparisons for social values.The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1927
- Zur Theorie der linearen und nicht linearen Integralgleichungen Zweite AbhandlungMathematische Annalen, 1907