Can Extractive Industries Promote Sustainable Development? A Net Benefits Framework and a Case Study of the Marlin Mine in Guatemala
Authors:
- 23 April 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The Journal of Environment & Development
- Vol. 22 (2) , 131-154
Abstract
This article develops a framework to evaluate net benefits from mining and utilizes it to assess the Marlin mine in Guatemala. The framework integrates “weak” and “strong” sustainability principles. Under weak sustainability, a net gain in human welfare can substitute for the loss of nonrenewable resources. Under strong sustainability, nature’s life-support systems are not substitutable. We define “net benefits” as the joint generation of net gains to human welfare, defined as local acceptance and high economic benefits, and low risks to the resilience of environmental life-support systems, especially water, evidenced by best practice management standards. We find little evidence that the Marlin mine meets either weak or strong sustainability criteria: there is strong local resistance to the mine and economic benefits are low, while environmental risk is high, especially in terms of potential long-term contamination of life-supporting ground and surface water.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Oil Politics and Indigenous Resistance in the Peruvian AmazonThe Journal of Environment & Development, 2012
- A Rich Vein? Mining and the Pursuit of Sustainability2010
- Towards a sustainability criteria and indicators framework for legacy mine landJournal of Cleaner Production, 2009
- Weak and strong sustainability in the SEEA: Concepts and measurementEcological Economics, 2007
- The emperors new clothes: Sustainable mining?Journal of Cleaner Production, 2006
- Sustainability and gold mining in the developing worldJournal of Cleaner Production, 2006
- Developing a framework for sustainable development indicators for the mining and minerals industryJournal of Cleaner Production, 2004
- A framework for the practical application of the concepts of critical natural capital and strong sustainabilityEcological Economics, 2003
- Assessment of the performance and sustainability of mining sub-soil assets for economic development in South AfricaEcological Economics, 2002
- The valuation of health impacts in developing countries2001