“It's Not the Climate, Stupid”: Exploring Nonideal Scenarios for Solar Geoengineering Development
Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Ethics & International Affairs
- Vol. 38 (3) , 255-274
Abstract
As part of the “Solar Geoengineering: Ethics, Governance, and International Politics” roundtable, this essay examines dilemmas arising in exploring nonideal scenarios of solar geoengineering deployment. Model-based knowledge about solar geoengineering tells us little about possible climatic responses to malicious, self-interested, or competing deployments, and even less about political or cultural responses outside of the climate system. The essay argues that policy for governing solar geoengineering in a world of multiple states and uneven power relations requires a broader base for solar geoengineering knowledge, beyond that offered by modeling, and a better understanding of nonideal scenarios, especially those motivated by logics beyond reducing climate impacts. It highlights the interests of military and security actors in such knowledge, and the potential for it to facilitate securitization and further reduce the prospect of multilateral collaborative governance of geoengineering in the public interest. The essay concludes that further research can be ethically justified but must be comprehensively governed.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- “Cooling credits” are not a viable climate solutionClimatic Change, 2023
- Dimming the midnight sun? Implications of the Sámi Council's intervention against the SCoPEx projectFrontiers in Climate, 2023
- Solar geoengineering is scary — that’s why we should research itNature, 2023
- Climate emergency and securitization politics: towards a climate politics of the extraordinaryGlobalizations, 2022
- Solar geoengineering: The case for an international non‐use agreementWires Climate Change, 2022
- Geoengineering: Symmetric precautionScience, 2021
- Democracy in a Global EmergencyDemocratic Theory, 2020
- Mitigation deterrence and the “moral hazard” of solar radiation managementEarth's Future, 2016
- ‘In case of emergency press here’: framing geoengineering as a response to dangerous climate changeWires Climate Change, 2013
- The Geoengineering Model Intercomparison Project (GeoMIP)Atmospheric Science Letters, 2011