Recommendations for additional imaging of abdominal imaging examinations: frequency, benefit, and cost
Authors:
Open Access
- 26 August 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Radiology
- Vol. 30 (2) , 1137-1144
Abstract
Objectives To investigate the frequency, determinants, clinical implications, and costs of recommendations for additional imaging (RAIs) in secondary interpretations of abdominal imaging examinations. Methods This retrospective study included 2225 abdominal imaging examinations from outside institutions that were reinterpreted as part of standard clinical care at a tertiary care center in a one-year time frame. Results Two hundred forty-six RAIs were present in 231 of 2225 reports (10.4%) of secondary abdominal imaging interpretations. Patient age and experience of the radiologist who performed the secondary interpretation were independently significantly associated with the presence of an RAI (both p = 0.002), with odds ratios of 0.99 per year increase in patient age (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.98–1.00) and 1.06 per year increase in experience of the radiologist (95% CI, 1.02–1.10). If followed, RAIs changed clinical management in 31.2%. Total costs of all 246 RAIs, whether performed or not by the referring physicians, amounted to €71,032.21, thus resulting in €31.92 per secondary abdominal imaging interpretation. Total costs of the 140 RAIs that were actually performed by the referring physicians amounted to €42,683.08, resulting in €19.18 per secondary abdominal imaging interpretation. Conclusions The frequency of RAIs in reports of secondary interpretations of abdominal imaging examinations (which appear to be affected by patients’ age and radiologists’ experience) and associated costs are non-negligible. However, RAIs not infrequently change clinical management. The presented data may be helpful to radiology departments and healthcare policy makers to make well-informed decisions on the value and facilitation of the practice of secondary interpretations. Key Points • Frequency of recommendations for additional imaging (RAIs) in secondary interpretations of abdominal imaging examinations at a tertiary care center is approximately 10.4%. • RAIs appear to be more frequently issued in younger patients and by more experienced radiologists, and if followed by referring clinicians, change clinical management in about one third of cases. • RAI costs per secondary interpretation in the Dutch Healthcare system are €31.92 (considering all RAIs) or €19.18 (considering only those RAIs that are actually performed).Keywords
Funding Information
- Universitair Medisch Centrum Groningen
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Second-Opinion Interpretations of Gynecologic Oncologic MRI Examinations by Sub-Specialized Radiologists Influence Patient CareEuropean Radiology, 2015
- Correlation of the Strength of Recommendations for Additional Imaging to Adherence Rate and Diagnostic YieldJournal of the American College of Radiology, 2015
- Diagnosis of Extracapsular Extension of Prostate Cancer on Prostate MRI: Impact of Second-Opinion Readings by Subspecialized Genitourinary Oncologic RadiologistsAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 2015
- Strategies for Avoiding Recommendations for Additional Imaging Through a Comprehensive Comparison With Prior StudiesJournal of the American College of Radiology, 2015
- The clinical impact of subspecialized radiologist reinterpretation of abdominal imaging studies, with analysis of the types and relative frequency of interpretation discrepanciesAbdominal Radiology, 2014
- MRI of the prostate: Interobserver agreement compared with histopathologic outcome after radical prostatectomyEuropean Journal of Radiology, 2012
- Recommendations for Additional Imaging in Radiology Reports: Multifactorial Analysis of 5.9 Million ExaminationsRadiology, 2009
- Effect of Directed Training on Reader Performance for CT Colonography: Multicenter StudyRadiology, 2007
- Shared Patient AnalysisMedical Care, 2001
- Standardized Abnormal Interpretation and Cancer Detection Ratios to Assess Reading Volume and Reader Performance in a Breast Screening ProgramRadiology, 2000