Efficiency factors of recycled concrete bottle-shaped struts
Authors:
- 1 April 2014
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Structures and Buildings
- Vol. 167 (4) , 230-242
Abstract
Reported test results of reinforced concrete beams made with coarse recycled concrete aggregate have been re-analysed using strut-and-tie models and the efficiency factors of the recycled concrete aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts compared with those made of natural coarse aggregate. The objective was to ascertain whether strut-and-tie model provisions for efficiency factors of bottle-shaped struts in current design codes and the recent literature, originally meant for natural coarse aggregate concrete, can be conservatively applied to recycled concrete aggregate concrete, or not. The results of the re-analysis indicate that the efficiency factors of the natural coarse aggregate as well as the recycled concrete aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts were comparable and conservative when benchmarked against the predictions of CSA A23.3-04 and an efficiency factor model proposed by the authors. However, both ACI 318-08 and Eurocode 2 gave unsafe efficiency factor predictions for the recycled concrete aggregate as well as the natural coarse aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts under investigation. This is attributed to the insensitivity of these two codes to strut inclination with adjoining tie(s) and does not per se indicate any inherent inferiority as far as recycled concrete aggregate concrete is concerned. This investigation indicates that recycled concrete aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts can be designed using the efficiency factors recommended for natural coarse aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts in CSA A23.3-04. Reported test results of reinforced concrete beams made with coarse recycled concrete aggregate have been re-analysed using strut-and-tie models and the efficiency factors of the recycled concrete aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts compared with those made of natural coarse aggregate. The objective was to ascertain whether strut-and-tie model provisions for efficiency factors of bottle-shaped struts in current design codes and the recent literature, originally meant for natural coarse aggregate concrete, can be conservatively applied to recycled concrete aggregate concrete, or not. The results of the re-analysis indicate that the efficiency factors of the natural coarse aggregate as well as the recycled concrete aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts were comparable and conservative when benchmarked against the predictions of CSA A23.3-04 and an efficiency factor model proposed by the authors. However, both ACI 318-08 and Eurocode 2 gave unsafe efficiency factor predictions for the recycled concrete aggregate as well as the natural coarse aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts under investigation. This is attributed to the insensitivity of these two codes to strut inclination with adjoining tie(s) and does not per se indicate any inherent inferiority as far as recycled concrete aggregate concrete is concerned. This investigation indicates that recycled concrete aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts can be designed using the efficiency factors recommended for natural coarse aggregate concrete bottle-shaped struts in CSA A23.3-04.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effect of inclination on the strength of strutsMagazine of Concrete Research, 2011
- Effect of Detailing of Web Reinforcement on the Behavior of Bottle-shaped StrutsJournal of Advanced Concrete Technology, 2010
- Shear strength of reinforced recycled concrete beams with stirrupsMagazine of Concrete Research, 2010
- Experimental study on the shear strength of recycled aggregate concrete beamsMagazine of Concrete Research, 2010
- New Mixture Proportioning Method for Concrete Made with Coarse Recycled Concrete AggregateJournal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 2009
- Shear strength of reinforced recycled concrete beams without stirrupsMagazine of Concrete Research, 2009
- An appraisal of the ACI strut efficiency factorsMagazine of Concrete Research, 2009
- Danish Experiences with a Decade of Green ConcreteJournal of Advanced Concrete Technology, 2007
- Development of a Sustainable Concrete Waste Recycling SystemJournal of Advanced Concrete Technology, 2007
- Evaluation of Efficiency Factor Models used in Strut-and-Tie Modeling of Nonflexural MembersJournal of Structural Engineering, 2002