Ability grouping of gifted students: Effects on academic self‐concept and boredom
- 1 September 2010
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Educational Psychology
- Vol. 80 (3) , 451-472
Abstract
Background: Securing appropriate challenge or preventing boredom is one of the reasons frequently used to justify ability grouping of gifted students, which has been shown to have beneficial effects for achievement. On the other hand, critics stress psychosocial costs, such as detrimental effects on academic self‐concept (contrast or big‐fish‐little‐pond effect). Aim: The effects of full‐time ability grouping in special classrooms for the gifted on students' academic self‐concept and their experience of boredom in mathematics classes were investigated. Sample: The sample comprised 186 ninth‐grade students (106 male) from eight classes at one Austrian high school. Four of these classes were part of a gifted track beginning from school year 9 on ( N = 93). Method: Students were assessed repeatedly within the first half of the school year, three times via self‐report questionnaires and once by applying a standardized IQ‐test. Results and conclusions: Students in gifted classes reported a decrease in maths academic self‐concept which was most pronounced early in the academic year. Interventions to counterbalance the negative effect of exposure to a high‐ability reference group should therefore be implemented when ability grouping begins. No evidence for the boredom hypothesis was found (higher levels of boredom among gifted students in regular classes). However, students clearly differed in the reasons they stated for experiencing boredom. Boredom attributions changed over time and supported the assumption that gifted classes provide more appropriate levels of challenge.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Big-fish–little-pond-effect Stands Up to Critical Scrutiny: Implications for Theory, Methodology, and Future ResearchEducational Psychology Review, 2008
- The Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect: What Do We Know and Where Do We Go from Here?Educational Psychology Review, 2008
- Grouping the Gifted and Talented: Are Gifted Girls Most Likely to Suffer the Consequences?Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 2008
- The Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect Stands Up to Scrutiny.American Psychologist, 2004
- It's Not How the Pond Makes You Feel, but Rather How High You Can Jump.American Psychologist, 2004
- Secondary Student Perceptions of Their Class Activities Regarding Meaningfulness, Challenge, Choice, and Appeal: An Initial Validation StudyJournal of Secondary Gifted Education, 2002
- Roles of Boredom and Life Goals in Juvenile Delinquency1Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2001
- Gifted, Streamed and Mixed-Ability Programs for Gifted Students: Impact on Self-Concept, Motivation, and AchievementAustralian Journal of Education, 2000
- Challenge or boredom?Gifted students’ views on their schoolingRoeper Review, 1997
- Grouping the gifted and talented:Questions and answersRoeper Review, 1993