Statistical modeling of vigor ratings in ruzigrass breeding
Authors:
- Jales Mendes Oliveira FonsecaJFJales Mendes Oliveira Fonseca
- Flavia Maria Avelar GonçalvesFGFlavia Maria Avelar Gonçalves
- Fausto Souza SobrinhoFSFausto Souza Sobrinho
- Júlio Sílvio de Souza Bueno FilhoJFJúlio Sílvio de Souza Bueno Filho
- Flávio Rodrigo Gandolfi BenitesFBFlávio Rodrigo Gandolfi Benites
- Davi Henrique Lima TeixeiraDTDavi Henrique Lima Teixeira
- José Airton Rodrigues NunesJNJosé Airton Rodrigues Nunes
Open Access
- 8 November 2024
- journal article
- Published by Universidade Estadual de Maringa in Acta Scientiarum. Agronomy
- Vol. 47 (1) , e72493
Abstract
Ruzigass (Urochloa ruziziensis) is a forage crop with high agronomic and nutritional value. Plant breeders often assess ruzigrass phenotypic traits via vigor ratings. The analyses of these categorical data often fail to meet the usual statistical assumptions. In this study, we compared four fittings of linear models for vigor rating analyses: i) a linear mixed model for the original scale (LMM), ii) a linear mixed model for a Box–Cox transformed scale (BCLMM), iii) a multinomial generalized mixed model using a probit link function, also known as threshold model (GLMM), and iv) a hierarchical Bayesian model, also referred to as a Bayesian threshold model (HBM). Additionally, biomass yield was assessed, and the indirect selection of high-performing genotypes was evaluated. The experimental design included 2,204 ruzigrass genotypes randomized into augmented blocks. Six graders visually assessed each plot using a rating scale. Fitting methods were sampled from three scenarios, employing one, three, or six graders. A nonnull genetic variance component was detected for vigor and biomass yield traits. Except for BCLMM, the methods for analyzing vigor ratings were correlated. The correlations and coincidence indices for selecting genotypes increased with the number of graders. The analysis of vigor ratings under Gaussian approximations is riskier when a single grader is used to evaluate genotypes. The GLMM and HBM perform similarly and are more recommended and suitable analyses of vigor ratings when selecting high-performing ruzigrass genotypes.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating general combining ability for agro-morphological traits in tetraploid bahiagrassEuphytica, 2021
- Herbage accumulation and nutritive value of cultivar Mulato II, Congo grass, and Guinea grass cultivar C1 in a subhumid zone of West AfricaAgronomy Journal, 2021
- Experimental assessment of the accuracy of genomic selection in sugarcaneTheoretical and Applied Genetics, 2013
- Correlations between visual biomass scores and forage yield in space planted red clover (Trifolium pratense L.) breeding nurseriesEuphytica, 2009
- An Introduction to Categorical Data Analysis2006
- Generalized Linear Mixed Models2005
- Categorical Data Analysis2002
- Modern Applied Statistics with S2002
- Fitting Regression Models to Ordinal DataBiometrical Journal, 1991
- Breeding Common Bean for Yield in Mixtures1986