An infinite family of counterexamples to a question of the Caminas
Author:
- 5 November 2026
- journal article
- Published by World Scientific Pub Co Pte Ltd in Journal of Algebra and Its Applications
Abstract
A.R. Camina and R.D. Camina posed the following question: Suppose there are two finite groups, one nilpotent and the other non-nilpotent, and the two groups share identical sets of conjugacy class sizes; must the non-nilpotent group possess a nontrivial center? Recently, W. Zhou gave a negative answer via a subtle and elegant construction of concrete counterexamples. Nevertheless, his approach relies on the existence of Sophie Germain primes, and thus fails to yield infinitely many counterexamples unconditionally. In this paper, we construct an infinite family of counterexamples to the Caminas’ question.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (12671032)