Legal Liability and the Uncertain Nature of Risk Prediction: The Case of Breast Cancer Risk Prediction Models
Authors:
Open Access
- 12 September 2012
- journal article
- review article
- Published by S. Karger AG in Public Health Genomics
- Vol. 15 (6) , 335-340
Abstract
Background: The rapidity of technological change in genetics is not always matched by the uptake of this new knowledge into practice. Increasing genetic knowledge has already led to legal liability for those who have not used it properly, such as not informing patients or their families of potential genetic risk. A similar outcome is also of concern in the case of risk prediction models used for hereditary breast cancer. Results: No legal case has directly addressed the use of risk prediction models. However, as genetic medicine and risk prediction models become more widely used, the prospect of a lawsuit will also increase. Current case law is instructive on the circumstances under which medical liability actions could be pursued and circumstances under which liability is unlikely, such as the provision of faulty family history information by a patient. Conclusions: There is existing case law on family history and genetics that parallels in many respects the use of risk prediction models. However, the idea of a bad ‘prediction’ is a difficult legal concept. Outside of a plain misuse or failure to use a risk prediction model when circumstances clearly required it, there is little legal guidance presently available to determine the risk for medical liability.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- A systematic review of breast cancer incidence risk prediction models with meta-analysis of their performanceBreast Cancer Research and Treatment, 2011
- Physician Liability: The Next Big Thing for Personalized Medicine?Personalized Medicine, 2011
- Predicting BRCA1 and BRCA2 gene mutation carriers: comparison of PENN II model to previous studyFamilial Cancer, 2010
- National Institutes of Health State-of-the-Science Conference Statement: Family History and Improving HealthAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2009
- The Dawning Era of Personalized Medicine Exposes a Gap in Medical EducationPLOS Medicine, 2009
- Predicting the likelihood of carrying a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation: validation of BOADICEA, BRCAPRO, IBIS, Myriad and the Manchester scoring system using data from UK genetics clinicsJournal of Medical Genetics, 2008
- The Comprehensiveness of Family Cancer History Assessments in Primary CarePublic Health Genomics, 2007
- Claims, Errors, and Compensation Payments in Medical Malpractice LitigationNew England Journal of Medicine, 2006
- The Educational Needs and Professional Roles of Canadian Physicians and Nurses regarding Genetic Testing and Adult Onset Hereditary DiseasePublic Health Genomics, 2005
- FAMILY HISTORY OF BREAST CANCER AS A RISK INDICATOR FOR THE DISEASEAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 1980