The impact of journal re-grading on perception of ranking systems: Exploring the case of the Academic Journal Guide and Business and Management scholars in the UK
Open Access
- 27 April 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Research Evaluation
- Vol. 28 (3) , 218-231
Abstract
The marked increase in the use of metrics, such as journal lists, to assess research has had a profound effect on academics’ working lives. While some view the diffusion of rankings as beneficial, others consider their diffusion as a malicious development, which further acerbates a tendency towards managerialism in academia, and undermine the integrity and diversity of academic research. Using data from a large-scale survey and a re-grading of journals in a ranking used by Business and Management UK scholars—the Academic Journal Guide—as a pseudo-experiment, we examine what determines negative and positive perceptions of rankings. We find that the individuals who published in outlets that were upgraded were less hostile to the ranking than those who did not benefit from these changes, and that individuals were also less hostile to the ranking if outlets in their field had benefited from re-grading in the new list. We also find that the individuals who published in outlets that were upgraded were more positive to the ranking than those who did not benefit from these changes, and that individuals were also more positive to the ranking if outlets in their field had benefited from re-grading in the new list.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Creating a Leading Journal and Maintaining Academic FreedomJournal of Change Management, 2013
- Taylorizing business school research: On the ‘one best way’ performative effects of journal ranking listsHuman Relations, 2012
- Performance-based university research funding systemsResearch Policy, 2012
- Affective organizational commitment and organizational citizenship behavior: examining the relationship through the lens of equity sensitivityOrganization Management Journal, 2011
- Theoretical and Interpretation Challenges to Using the Author Affiliation Index Method to Rank JournalsProduction and Operations Management, 2011
- Producing Spaces for Academic Discourse: The Impact of Research Assessment Exercises and Journal Quality RankingsAustralian Accounting Review, 2010
- Rankings and the battle for world-class excellenceHigher Education Management and Policy, 2009
- The Impact of League Tables and Ranking Systems on Higher Education Decision MakingHigher Education Management and Policy, 2007
- The UK research assessment exerciseHuman Resource Development International, 2005
- Academic careers, patents, and productivity: industry experience as scientific and technical human capitalResearch Policy, 2005