Reproducibility of Plantar Pressure Measurements in Patients with Chronic Arthritis: A Comparison of One-Step, Two-Step, and Three-Step Protocols and an Estimate of the Number of Measurements Required
- 1 October 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Foot & Ankle International
- Vol. 25 (10) , 739-744
Abstract
Background: Plantar pressure measurement may be a helpful evaluation tool in patients with foot complaints. Determination of dynamic pressure distribution under the foot may give information regarding gait, progress of disorders, and the effect of treatment. However, for these measurements to have clinical application, reproducibility, consistency, and accuracy must be ascertained. We compared the reproducibility of measurements among one-step, two-step, and three-step protocols for data collection in patients with arthritis. In addition, the number of measurements needed for a consistent average was determined for the protocol that was found to be the most reproducible. Methods: Twenty patients with foot complaints secondary to arthritis participated in the study. Each patient was tested with a pressure platform system using two of the three testing protocols. Reproducibility of contact time and maximal peak pressure were assessed. Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICC) were calculated for measurement results among protocols. In stage two of the study, the number of measurements needed for a consistent average was determined by calculating the first three measurements, the first five measurements, and then all seven measurements for both feet. ICC of three, five, and seven measurements were compared. The two-step protocol (13 patients), which was found in stage one of the study to be the most reproducible, was used for this determination. Results: Reproducibility was found to be reasonable or good for all three measurement protocols. The mean values of contact time for the one-step protocol were found to be higher than the mean values of contact time for the two-step or three-step protocols in both feet. The differences between the one-step and three-step protocols were statistically significant for the left foot only. The mean peak pressure did not show statistically-significant differences among the three protocols. The one-step and three-step protocols were not used for stage two of the study. Using the two-step protocol, three measurements were found to be sufficient for obtaining a consistent average. Conclusions: The results of our study indicated that the one-step, two-step, and three-step protocols of collecting plantar pressure measurements in patients with foot complaints secondary to chronic arthritis were all similar. However, the use of the two-step protocol is recommended over the one-step and three-step protocols; the one-step protocol produced a longer stance phase that did not resemble normal walking and when comparing the two-step and three-step protocols, the two-step protocol was less time consuming and less strenuous for patients with painful feet.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Normal values of plantar pressure measurements determined using the EMED-SF systemJournal of the American Podiatric Medical Association, 2000
- Comparison of the Reliability of Plantar Pressure Measurements Using the Two-step and Midgait Methods of Data CollectionFoot & Ankle International, 1999
- Variability of plantar pressure data. A comparison of the two-step and midgait methodsJournal of the American Podiatric Medical Association, 1999
- Reliability of F-Scan In-Shoe Measurements of Plantar PressureFoot & Ankle International, 1998
- Is there a critical level of plantar foot pressure to identify patients at risk for neuropathic foot ulceration?The Journal of Foot and Ankle Surgery, 1998
- Impairment assessment in rehabilitation medicine: the potential role of technology to assist clinical decision making.Disability and Rehabilitation, 1998
- Investigation of gait protocols for plantar pressure measurement of non-pathological subjects using a dynamic pedobarographGait & Posture, 1997
- Comparison of three methods for obtaining plantar pressures in nonpathologic subjectsJournal of the American Podiatric Medical Association, 1994
- Reliability of pressure measurements: the EM ED F systemClinical Biomechanics, 1991
- The american rheumatism association 1987 revised criteria for the classification of rheumatoid arthritisArthritis & Rheumatism, 1988