Climate-related disasters are increasing in frequency and severity, yet households hold incomplete insurance coverage even in high-risk areas. This paper examines whether insurance uptake is driven by objectively measured disaster exposure or by individuals’ subjective perceptions of climate risk. Using data from the Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) survey matched with postcode-level climate risk indicators, we estimate probit models of housing insurance uptake while distinguishing between perceived and objective risk. The results show that subjective risk perception significantly increases the probability of purchasing comprehensive housing insurance, whereas objectively measured hazard exposure is not significantly associated with insurance decisions. Instrumental-variable estimates exploiting spatial disaster salience provide suggestive evidence that perceived risk remains a strong predictor of insurance uptake after accounting for potential endogeneity. Furthermore, heterogeneity analysis indicates that liquidity constraints weaken the relationship between perceived risk and insurance purchase. Overall, we show that insurance demand is more strongly associated with perception-driven behavioural responses than with objective risk, and that this divergence—amplified by financial constraints—contributes to systematic underinsurance.