The Dizzy Spells of AI: Enacting Intellectual Independence in AI Literacy and AI-Mediated Learning
Open Access
- 30 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Human-Centric Intelligent Systems
- Vol. 6 (3) , 390-411
Abstract
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into education and learning risks leading to intellectual dependence among users of AI tools. Meanwhile, intellectual dependence remains underexplored in AI-mediated learning and is addressed ambiguously in AI literacy programmes, which claim to foster critical thinking (CT) and critical consciousness (CC) among learners, helping them move from naïve to more critical ways of thinking about and using AI. However, such approaches to AI literacy often presume and reinforce a hierarchy of thought: teachers are seen as critical thinkers about AI, while students are viewed as less so. This hierarchy arguably leads to intellectual dependence of the latter on the former. In this paper, we problematise AI literacy programmes that embrace CT and CC as educational objectives, since, as we argue, they remedy intellectual dependence on AI tools (e.g. ChatGPT, Claude…) by subjecting AI users/learners to another intellectual dependence, but on AI teachers. By drawing on Jacques Rancière’s ideas of universal intellectual equality, we argue that enacting intellectual independence is not an educational or learning goal to be achieved in the future, but a starting point—a condition necessary for teaching and learning about and with AI. Hence, we apply this assumption of equality of intelligence to both AI literacy and AI-mediated learning, and illustrate this application with two practical scenarios: (1) AI-centred pedagogy (thing-centred AI literacy) and (2) ignorant AI-tutors (thing-centred AI-mediated learning). Both approaches aim to reduce dependence on human teachers in AI literacy or on AI tutors in AI-mediated learning. Ultimately, this paper presents design principles for these two solutions, offers a philosophical premise for rethinking education, teaching, and learning in the age of AI, and concludes with contributions, limitations, and a research agenda.Keywords
Funding Information
- VINNOVA (2023-02579)
This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- Enhancing Critical Thinking in Education by Means of a Socratic Chatbot2025
- Perspectives on AI literacy in Middle School Classrooms: An Integrative ReviewPostdigital Science and Education, 2025
- Can ChatGPT Be Addictive? A Call to Examine the Shift from Support to Dependence in AI Conversational Large Language ModelsHuman-Centric Intelligent Systems, 2025
- A Model for Understanding and Expanding the Scope of Critical ThinkingStudies in Philosophy and Education, 2025
- A review of AI teaching and learning from 2000 to 2020Education and Information Technologies, 2022
- An Emergent Reflexive Epistemology in Lifelong Learning2022
- Conceptualizing AI literacy: An exploratory reviewComputers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 2021
- The Singularity Hoax: Why Computers Will Never Be More Intelligent than Humans2020
- Against the Socratic Method2019
- Artificial Intelligence as a Socratic Assistant for Moral EnhancementNeuroethics, 2019