Ethnographic analogy from the Pacific: just as analogical as any other analogy
Author:
- 5 December 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in World Archaeology
- Vol. 43 (4) , 716-725
Abstract
This paper is a comment on previous papers in World Archaeology by Spriggs ( 2008 Spriggs, M. 2008. Ethnographic parallels and the denial of history. World Archaeology, 40(4): 538–52. [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] [Google Scholar] ) and Roscoe ( 2009 Roscoe, P. 2009. On the ‘pacification’ of the European Neolithic: ethnographic analogy and the neglect of history. World Archaeology, 41(4): 578–88. [Taylor & Francis Online], [Web of Science ®] [Google Scholar] ) on the use of Pacific analogies in archaeology. It is argued that the discussion needs to be put into a context of the general use of analogy, as Pacific analogies are just as analogical as any other analogy. Furthermore, the concern with analogy outlined by Spriggs and Roscoe is bound up in a dated definition of analogy which emphasizes similarities and assumes static societies. A better definition of analogy emphasizing not only similarities but differences and relevance is proposed. This definition makes it possible to modify analogies when confronted with refined archaeological data. Thus, we need not abolish the use of analogy, only use it in a more case-specific way, allowing for the ethnographic and archaeological record to modify the analogy and including the progress already reached through the study of analogy over the last sixty years.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Unification and Convergence in Archaeological Explanation: The Agricultural “Wave-of-Advance” and the Origins of Indo-European LanguagesThe Southern Journal of Philosophy, 1996
- Analogy in Danish prehistoric studiesNorwegian Archaeological Review, 1993
- Archaeological Cables and Tacking: The Implications of Practice for Bernstein's ‘Options Beyond Objectivism and Relativism’Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 1989
- ‘Simple’ analogy and the role of relevance assumptions: Implications of archaeological practiceInternational Studies in the Philosophy of Science, 1988
- The Archaeo-Ethnology of Hunter-Gatherers or the Tyranny of the Ethnographic Record in ArchaeologyAmerican Antiquity, 1978
- Comments on Binford's “Smudge Pits and Hide Smoking: The Use of Analogy in Archaeological Reasoning”American Antiquity, 1969
- Major Aspects of the Interrelationship of Archaeology and EthnologyCurrent Anthropology, 1967
- Smudge Pits and Hide Smoking: The Use of Analogy in Archaeological ReasoningAmerican Antiquity, 1967
- Archaeology as AnthropologyAmerican Antiquity, 1962
- Wenner‐Gren Foundation Supper ConferenceAmerican Anthropologist, 1954