The unpleasantness of thinking: A meta-analytic review of the association between mental effort and negative affect.
Top Cited Papers
- 5 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Psychological Bulletin
Abstract
Influential theories in psychology, neuroscience, and economics assume that the exertion of mental effort should feel aversive. Yet, this assumption is usually untested, and it is challenged by casual observations and previous studies. Here, we meta-analyze (a) whether mental effort is generally experienced as aversive and (b) whether the association between mental effort and aversive feelings depends on population and task characteristics. We meta-analyzed a set of 170 studies (from 125 articles published in 2019-2020; 358 different tasks; 4,670 unique subjects). These studies were conducted in a variety of populations (e.g., health care employees, military employees, amateur athletes, college students; data were collected in 29 different countries) and used a variety of tasks (e.g., equipment testing tasks, virtual reality tasks, cognitive performance tasks). Despite this diversity, these studies had one crucial common feature: All used the NASA Task Load Index to examine participants' experiences of effort and negative affect. As expected, we found a strong positive association between mental effort and negative affect. Surprisingly, just one of our 15 moderators had a significant effect (effort felt somewhat less aversive in studies from Asia vs. Europe and North America). Overall, mental effort felt aversive in different types of tasks (e.g., tasks with and without feedback), in different types of populations (e.g., university-educated populations and non-university-educated populations), and on different continents. Supporting theories that conceptualize effort as a cost, we suggest that mental effort is inherently aversive. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 180 references indexed in Scilit:
- Teleoperation of industrial robot manipulators based on augmented realityThe International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2020
- Learning curve of surgical novices using the single-port platform SymphonX: minimizing OR trauma to only one 15-mm incisionSurgical Endoscopy, 2020
- An experimental investigation of menu selection for immersive virtual environments: fixed versus handheld menusVirtual Reality, 2020
- Family health history collected by virtual conversational agents: An empirical study to investigate the efficacy of this approachJournal of Genetic Counseling, 2020
- Assessment and monitoring of mental workload in subway train operations using physiological, subjective, and performance measuresHuman Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing & Service Industries, 2020
- Operative performance outcomes of a simulator-based robotic surgical skills curriculumSurgical Endoscopy, 2019
- Effect of risk-predictive haptic guidance in one-pedal driving modeCognition, Technology & Work, 2019
- The Physical Activity Guidelines for AmericansJAMA, 2018
- Keeping the body in mind: Insula functional organization and functional connectivity integrate interoceptive, exteroceptive, and emotional awarenessHuman Brain Mapping, 2012
- Motivational correlates of need for cognitionEuropean Journal of Social Psychology, 2008