The prevalence effect in fingerprint identification: Match and non‐match base‐rates impact misses and false alarms
- 31 January 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Applied Cognitive Psychology
- Vol. 35 (3) , 751-760
Abstract
The prevalence effect is a phenomenon whereby target prevalence impacts performance in visual search (e.g., baggage screening) and visual comparison (e.g., face‐matching) tasks – people more often 'miss' infrequent target stimuli. The current study investigated prevalence effects in fingerprint identification – an important visual comparison task used in criminal investigations. Participants (N = 287) judged 100 fingerprint pairs where the prevalence of match trials was either 10% (low), 50% (equal), or 90% (high), and half received trial‐level feedback on their performance. As predicted, low match prevalence increased errors on match trials (i.e., misses), whereas high match prevalence errors on non‐match trials (i.e., false alarms) – but only when participants received feedback. These effects were largely driven by changes in bias (C), rather than sensitivity (d’). These results suggest that the combination of feedback and match prevalence can impact the types of errors that fingerprint examiners may make in practice.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (1823741)
- Towson University
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Visual Search of Experts in Medical Image Reading: The Effect of Training, Target Prevalence, and Expert KnowledgeFrontiers in Psychology, 2013
- Repeatability and Reproducibility of Decisions by Latent Fingerprint ExaminersPLOS ONE, 2012
- Accuracy and reliability of forensic latent fingerprint decisionsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2011
- Spatial and temporal separation fails to counteract the effects of low prevalence in visual searchVisual Cognition, 2010
- Varying Target Prevalence Reveals Two Dissociable Decision Criteria in Visual SearchCurrent Biology, 2010
- Why do we miss rare targets? Exploring the boundaries of the low prevalence effectJournal of Vision, 2008
- Gold versus platinum: Do jurors recognize the superiority and limitations of DNA evidence compared to other types of forensic evidence?Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 2008
- Rare Targets Are Rarely Missed in Correctable SearchPsychological Science, 2007
- Scientific validation of fingerprint evidence under DaubertLaw, Probability and Risk, 2007
- Low target prevalence is a stubborn source of errors in visual search tasks.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 2007