Nonbeneficial Treatment and Conflict Resolution: Building Consensus
- 1 September 2013
- journal article
- Published by The Permanente Federation in The Permanente Journal
- Vol. 17 (3) , 23-27
Abstract
We established a fair and explicit nonbeneficial treatment and conflict resolution policy at our medical center. The policy was designed to help us acknowledge and respect both patients and clinicians involved in treatment planning and decision making. To qualitatively describe how our hospitalwide nonbeneficial treatment and conflict resolution policy was used. Retrospective evaluation of all bioethics consultations from November 6, 2009, when the policy was adopted, through August 6, 2012. Case-specific data were obtained when nonconsensus occurred involving withholding or withdrawing of nonbeneficial treatment. Rates of resolution of conflicts and treatment plan consensus when nonbeneficial treatment was withheld or withdrawn. We identified 146 (39.4%) cases where there was a treatment-level conflict between patients/surrogates and the treatment teams responsible for their care. In 54 (37.0%) of the cases, resolution occurred. In 92 (63.0%) of the cases, nonbeneficial treatment was eventually withheld or withdrawn. In 87 (94.6%) of the cases where treatment was withheld or withdrawn, the treatment teams and patients/surrogates reached consensus by the conclusion of the bioethics consultation process using the fair and explicit nonbeneficial treatment and conflict resolution policy. A fair and explicit nonbeneficial treatment and conflict resolution policy can result in a high level of consensus between patients/surrogates and the treatment teams responsible for their care when treatment is withheld or withdrawn.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Living With Advanced Illness: Longitudinal Study of Patient, Family, and Caregiver NeedsThe Permanente Journal, 2012
- The Familiar Foundation and the Fuller Sense: Ethics Consultation and NarrativeThe Permanente Journal, 2012
- Using Qualitative Methods To Explore Key Questions in Palliative CareJournal of Palliative Medicine, 2009
- Futility, Conscientious Refusal, and Who Gets to DecideThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2008
- Fair and Just Culture, Team Behavior, and Leadership Engagement: The Tools to Achieve High ReliabilityHealth Services Research, 2006
- Precedent Autonomy and Subsequent ConsentEthical Theory and Moral Practice, 2004
- Conscientious Refusal and a Doctors?s Right to QuitThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2004
- Informed Consent: Does It Take a Village? The Problem of Culture and Truth TellingCambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 2001