Abstract
A systematic review (SR) is the unbiased appraisal of systematically identified relevant studies. Implicit in its definition is a robust and scientifically valid process, and when performed as such, SR is an important clinical research tool and influence in health policy decision‐making. This educational paper outlines that, from the original prototype based on randomized trials, there are now many other types of SRs including those based on: nonrandomized comparative studies, observational studies, prognostic studies, and studies of diagnostic and screening tools. While each of these has a similar ‘anatomy’ or format, at an individual class level, there are principles specific to each SR type. Several examples from the coloproctology literature are used as case‐studies to illustrate potential pitfalls, and upon re‐analysis, often reverse or attenuate the conclusions stated in the original publication. These examples serve to emphasize the need for health professionals to understand the process of SR and meta‐analysis so that we all arrive at appropriate interpretations to the benefit of our patients.

This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit: