Abstract
The territorial/local level of action appears to be a key level for making environmental protection decisions, as well as a valuable level of sociological analysis. Based on two very different examples (France, Quebec) involving the protection of drinking water, this article looks at justice-related processes that enable reflection on environmental problems and the ways they are resolved on a territorial scale, in other words, justice as a process of normative judgment. The article therefore shows that environmental actions are permeable to social power relationships. It is in this context of environmental decision making that the justice–environment relationship plays out. However, if the local appears to be the level at which environmental issues are addressed, it rarely produces solutions in favour of nature or natural resource protection. To the contrary, it generates decisions based on ‘just inequalities’ associated with local political and economic arbitration. In this context, two generic models of environmental governance seem to emerge: one ‘by withdrawal’ and the other ‘by obstruction.’ Both underscore the persistence of an unjust sustainability with respect to natural resources.

This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit: